School of Biological Sciences, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
School of Media and Communication, RMIT University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Plant Biol (Stuttg). 2020 Jul;22(4):555-561. doi: 10.1111/plb.13113. Epub 2020 Apr 18.
About one-third of orchid species are thought to offer no floral reward and therefore attract pollinators through deception. Statements of this idea are common in the botanical literature, but the empirical basis of the estimate is rarely mentioned. We traced citation pathways for the one-third estimate in a sample of the literature and found that the paths lead to empirical foundations that are surprisingly narrow. Moreover, recent measurements have detected minute quantities of sugar available to insect visitors in some orchids thought to be rewardless, raising the possibility of a pollination strategy that is largely deceitful but different to absolute rewardlessness. The orchids are a well-studied group and there is no doubt that rewardlessness is common in the family. However, greater empirical effort is needed to verify rewardlessness in orchids and to explore geographic and environmental variation in the proportion of rewardless species.
据认为,大约三分之一的兰花物种没有提供花朵奖励,因此通过欺骗来吸引传粉者。这种观点在植物学文献中很常见,但很少提到这种估计的经验基础。我们在文献样本中追踪了三分之一的估计的引文路径,发现这些路径指向的经验基础非常狭窄。此外,最近的测量发现,在一些被认为没有奖励的兰花中,昆虫访客可以获得微量的糖,这增加了一种主要是欺骗性但与绝对无奖励不同的传粉策略的可能性。兰花是一个研究得很好的群体,毫无疑问,在这个家族中,没有奖励是很常见的。然而,需要更多的经验努力来验证兰花的无奖励性,并探索无奖励物种比例的地理和环境变化。