Minaei Hossein, Peikanpour Mohammad, Yousefi Nazila, Peymani Payam, Peiravian Farzad, Shobeiri Nikta, Karimi Majd Zahra, Shamsaee Javad
Department of Pharmacoeconomics and Pharma Management, School of Pharmacy, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
H. M. and M. P. contributed equally to this work.
Iran J Pharm Res. 2019 Fall;18(4):2191-2203. doi: 10.22037/ijpr.2019.111636.13273.
Evaluation of pharmaceutical systems performance is an essential prerequisite for promoting evidence-based policy-making and improvement in health system performance. This study attempts to evaluate the performance of Iran pharmaceutical system based on the world health organization (WHO)'s indicators, including access, quality, and rational use of medicines. In this cross-sectional descriptive study, inspired by the instructions proposed by WHO, public and private pharmaceutical service-providers were evaluated in three dimensions and 16 indicators. Accordingly, eleven separate checklists were developed and, in terms of translation, face and content validity were certified by pharmaceutical sector's experts. Sampling was randomly carried out in five cities. Depending on the type of indicators, retrospective or prospective approaches was determined for data collection. The data were collected from April to November 2018 and analyzed by SPSS 24. The availability of targeted key medicines in various cities as well as in public and private pharmacies was 97.5% with no significant difference. Although the medicines cost was higher in private sectors than in public ones, they were affordable in both sectors. In quality indicators, public sectors enjoyed a higher level than the private sectors did. The average number of medicines per prescription in public pharmacies was 3.2 and it was 3.4 in private ones. On average, in public sectors 33% and 32% of outpatients received antibiotics and injectable medicines, respectively. Finally, 77% of medicines were prescribed by using their generic names and 25% of prescriptions were in accordance with key medicines list. This study reveals that the availability and affordability of targeted key medicines in Iran are in good condition; however, in terms of rational use of medicines, Iran fails to meet the standard levels.
评估药品系统绩效是促进循证决策和改善卫生系统绩效的重要前提。本研究试图根据世界卫生组织(WHO)的指标,包括药品的可及性、质量和合理使用,来评估伊朗药品系统的绩效。在这项横断面描述性研究中,受WHO提出的指导方针启发,从三个维度和16项指标对公共和私营药品服务提供者进行了评估。据此,制定了11份单独的检查表,并在翻译方面,由制药行业专家认证了表面效度和内容效度。在五个城市进行了随机抽样。根据指标类型,确定采用回顾性或前瞻性方法收集数据。数据于2018年4月至11月收集,并使用SPSS 24进行分析。各城市以及公立和私立药店中目标关键药品的可及率为97.5%,无显著差异。虽然私营部门的药品成本高于公共部门,但两个部门的药品价格均在可承受范围内。在质量指标方面,公共部门的水平高于私营部门。公立药店每张处方的平均药品数量为3.2种,私立药店为3.4种。平均而言,在公共部门,分别有33%和32%的门诊患者接受了抗生素和注射用药品。最后,77%的药品使用通用名开具,25%的处方符合关键药品清单。本研究表明,伊朗目标关键药品的可及性和可承受性状况良好;然而,在药品合理使用方面,伊朗未达到标准水平。