Diao Yin-Ze, Yu Miao, Zhang Feng-Shan, Sun Yu, Wang Shao-Bo, Zhang Li, Pan Sheng-Fa, Liu Zhong-Jun, Li Wei-Shi
Department of Orthopedics, Institute of Spinal Surgery, Peking University Third Hospital; Beijing Key Laboratory of Spinal Disease, Beijing 100191, China.
Chin Med J (Engl). 2020 Apr 20;133(8):909-918. doi: 10.1097/CM9.0000000000000730.
Cervical posterior decompression surgery is used to relieve ventral compression indirectly by incorporating a backward shift of the spinal cord, and this indirect decompression is bound to be limited. This study aimed to determine the decompression limit of posterior surgery and the effect of the decompression range.
We retrospectively reviewed the data of 129 patients who underwent cervical open-door laminoplasty through 2008 to 2012 and were grouped as follows: C4-C7 (n = 11), C3-C6 (n = 61), C3-C7 (n = 32), and C2-C7 (n = 25). According to the relative location of spinal levels within a decompression range, the type of decompression at a given level was categorized as external decompression (ED; achieved at the levels located immediately external to the decompression range margin), internal decompression (ID; achieved at the levels located immediately internal to the decompression range margin), and central decompression (CD; achieved at the levels located in the center, far from the decompression range margin). The vertebral-cord distance (VCD) was used to evaluate the decompression limit. The C2-C7 angle and VCD on post-operative magnetic resonance images were analyzed and compared between groups. The relationship between VCD and decompression type was analyzed. Moreover, the relationship between the magnitude of the ventral compressive factor and the probability of post-operative residual compression at each level for different decompression ranges was studied.
There was no significant kyphosis in cervical curvature (> -5°), and there was no significant difference among the groups (F = 2.091, P = 0.105). The VCD of a specific level depended on the decompression type of the level and followed this pattern: ED < ID < CD (P < 0.05). The decompression type of a level was sometimes affected by the decompression range. For a given magnitude of the ventral compressive factor, the probability of residual compression was lower for the group with the larger VCD at this level.
Our study suggests that the decompression range affected the decompression limit by changing the decompression type of a particular level. For a given cervical spinal level, the decompression limit significantly varied with decompression type as follows: ED < ID < CD. CD provided maximal decompression limit for a given level. A reasonable range of decompression could be determined based on the relationship between the magnitude of the ventral compressive factor and the decompression limits achieved by different decompression ranges.
颈椎后路减压手术通过使脊髓向后移位来间接缓解腹侧压迫,而这种间接减压必然是有限的。本研究旨在确定后路手术的减压限度以及减压范围的影响。
我们回顾性分析了2008年至2012年接受颈椎开门椎板成形术的129例患者的数据,并将其分为以下几组:C4 - C7(n = 11)、C3 - C6(n = 61)、C3 - C7(n = 32)和C2 - C7(n = 25)。根据减压范围内脊髓节段的相对位置,将给定节段的减压类型分为外部减压(ED;在紧邻减压范围边缘外侧的节段实现)、内部减压(ID;在紧邻减压范围边缘内侧的节段实现)和中央减压(CD;在位于中心、远离减压范围边缘的节段实现)。采用椎-脊髓距离(VCD)评估减压限度。分析并比较了术后磁共振图像上各组之间的C2 - C7角度和VCD。分析了VCD与减压类型之间的关系。此外,研究了不同减压范围内腹侧压迫因素的大小与各节段术后残留压迫概率之间的关系。
颈椎曲度无明显后凸(> -5°),各组之间无显著差异(F = 2.091,P = 0.105)。特定节段的VCD取决于该节段的减压类型,且遵循以下模式:ED < ID < CD(P < 0.05)。一个节段的减压类型有时会受到减压范围的影响。对于给定大小的腹侧压迫因素,该节段VCD较大的组残留压迫的概率较低。
我们的研究表明,减压范围通过改变特定节段的减压类型影响减压限度。对于给定的颈椎节段,减压限度随减压类型显著变化,如下所示:ED < ID < CD。CD为给定节段提供了最大的减压限度。可根据腹侧压迫因素的大小与不同减压范围所达到的减压限度之间的关系确定合理的减压范围。