Dent Paul A, Wilke Benjamin, Terkonda Sarvram, Luther Ian, Shi Glenn G
Physics, Hampden-Sydney College, Farmville, USA.
Orthopaedics, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, USA.
Cureus. 2020 Feb 9;12(2):e6925. doi: 10.7759/cureus.6925.
Background Range of motion (ROM) is a critical component of a physician's evaluation for many consultations. The purpose of this study was to evaluate if teleconference goniometry could be as accurate as clinical goniometry. Methods Forty-eight volunteers participated in the study. There was a sample size of 52 elbows. Each measurement was recorded consecutively in person, through teleconference, and still-shot photography by two researchers trained in goniometry. Measurements of maximum elbow flexion and extension were taken and recorded. Results Teleconference goniometry had a high agreement with clinical goniometry (Pearson coefficient: flexion: 0.93, Extension: 0.87). Limits of agreement found from the Bland-Altman test were 7⁰ and -3⁰ for flexion and 10.4⁰ and -7.4⁰ for extension. A t-test revealed a P-value of less than 0.001 between teleconference and clinical measurements, proving the data are significant. Conclusions ROM measurements through a teleconferencing medium are comparable to clinical ROM measurements. This would allow for interactive elbow ROM assessment with the orthopedist without having to incorporate travel time and expenses.
背景 活动范围(ROM)是医生在许多会诊评估中的关键组成部分。本研究的目的是评估电话会议测角法是否能与临床测角法一样准确。方法 48名志愿者参与了该研究。共有52个肘部样本。由两名接受过测角法培训的研究人员亲自、通过电话会议以及静态摄影连续记录每次测量。测量并记录了肘部最大屈曲和伸展情况。结果 电话会议测角法与临床测角法高度一致(皮尔逊系数:屈曲为0.93,伸展为0.87)。布兰德 - 奥特曼检验得出的一致性界限为屈曲时7⁰和 -3⁰,伸展时10.4⁰和 -7.4⁰。t检验显示电话会议测量与临床测量之间的P值小于0.001,证明数据具有显著性。结论 通过电话会议媒介进行的ROM测量与临床ROM测量相当。这将允许与骨科医生进行交互式肘部ROM评估,而无需考虑出行时间和费用。