Volloch Vladimir, Olsen Bjorn R, Rits Sophia
Department of Developmental Biology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, USA.
Division of Molecular Medicine, Children's Hospital, Boston, USA.
Ann Integr Mol Med. 2020;2(1):75-89. doi: 10.33597/aimm.02-1006.
The present study posits that Alzheimer's disorder is a "fast" disease. This is in sharp contrast to a view, prevailing until now, that Alzheimer's Disease (AD) is a quintessential "slow" disease that develops throughout the life as one prolonged process. According to this view, beta-amyloid (Aβ) is produced and secreted solely by the beta-amyloid precursor protein (βAPP) proteolytic/secretory pathway. As its extracellular levels increase, it triggers neurodegeneration starting relatively early in life. Damages accumulate and manifest, late in life in sporadic Alzheimer's Disease (SAD) cases, as AD symptoms. In familial AD (FAD) cases, where mutations in βAPP gene or in presenilins increase production of either common Aβ isoform or of its more toxic isoforms, neurodegeneration reaches critical threshold sooner and AD symptoms occur earlier in life, mostly in late 40s and 50s. There are currently no preventive AD therapies but if they were available, according to this viewpoint it would be largely futile to intervene late in life in case of potential SAD or at mid-age in cases of FAD because, although AD symptoms have not yet manifested, the damage has already occurred during the preceding decades. In this paradigm, to be effective, preventive therapeutic intervention should be initiated early in life. The outlook suggested by the present study is radically different. According to it, Alzheimer's disease evolves in two stages. The first stage is a slow process of intracellular beta-amyloid accumulation. It occurs via βAPP proteolytic/secretory pathway and cellular uptake of secreted Aβ common to , including healthy humans, and to non-human mammals, and results neither in significant damage, nor in manifestation of the disease. The second stage occurs exclusively in humans, commences shortly before symptomatic onset of the disease, sharply accelerates the production and increases intracellular levels of Aβ that is not secreted but is retained intracellularly, generates significant damages, triggers AD symptoms, and is fast. It is driven by an Aβ generation pathway qualitatively and quantitatively different from βAPP proteolytic process and entirely independent of beta-amyloid precursor protein, and results in rapid and substantial intracellular accumulation of Aβ, consequent significant neurodegeneration, and symptomatic AD. In this paradigm, a preventive therapy for AD, an AD "statin", would be effective when initiated at any time prior to commencement of the second stage. Moreover, there are good reasons to believe that with a drug blocking βAPP-independent Aβ production pathway in the second stage, it would be possible not only to preempt the disease but also to stop and to reverse it even when early AD symptoms have already manifested. The present study posits a notion of AD as a Fast Disease, offers evidence for the occurrence of the AD-specific Aβ production pathway, describes cellular and molecular processes constituting an engine that drives Alzheimer's disease, and explains why non-human mammals are not susceptible to AD and why only a subset of humans develop the disease. It establishes that Alzheimer's disease is preventable by therapeutic intervention initiated even late in life, details a powerful mechanism underlying the disease, suggests that Aβ produced in the βAPP-independent pathway is retained intracellularly, elaborates why neither BACE inhibition nor Aβ immunotherapy are effective in treatment of AD and why intracellularly retained beta-amyloid could be the primary agent of neuronal death in Alzheimer's disease, necessitates generation of a novel animal AD model capable of producing Aβ via βAPP-independent pathway, proposes therapeutic targets profoundly different from previously pursued components of the βAPP proteolytic pathway, and provides conceptual rationale for design of drugs that could be used not only preemptively but also for treatment and reversal of the early stages of the disease.
本研究认为,阿尔茨海默病是一种“快速”疾病。这与迄今为止普遍存在的观点形成了鲜明对比,即阿尔茨海默病(AD)是一种典型的“缓慢”疾病,它在整个生命过程中作为一个长期的过程发展。根据这种观点,β-淀粉样蛋白(Aβ)仅由β-淀粉样前体蛋白(βAPP)的蛋白水解/分泌途径产生和分泌。随着其细胞外水平的增加,它在生命相对早期就引发神经退行性变。损害不断积累并在散发性阿尔茨海默病(SAD)病例的生命后期表现为AD症状。在家族性AD(FAD)病例中,βAPP基因或早老素的突变会增加常见Aβ异构体或其毒性更强的异构体的产生,神经退行性变更快达到临界阈值,AD症状在生命早期出现,大多在40多岁和50多岁。目前没有预防性的AD治疗方法,但如果有的话,根据这种观点,在潜在的SAD病例生命后期或FAD病例中年期进行干预基本上是徒劳的,因为尽管AD症状尚未显现,但损害在前几十年就已经发生了。在这种模式下,为了有效,预防性治疗干预应该在生命早期开始。本研究提出的观点则截然不同。根据该观点,阿尔茨海默病分两个阶段发展。第一阶段是细胞内β-淀粉样蛋白积累的缓慢过程。它通过βAPP蛋白水解/分泌途径以及包括健康人类和非人类哺乳动物在内的共同的分泌Aβ的细胞摄取而发生,既不会导致显著损害,也不会导致疾病表现。第二阶段仅发生在人类中,在疾病症状发作前不久开始,急剧加速Aβ的产生并增加细胞内未分泌但保留在细胞内的Aβ水平,产生显著损害,引发AD症状,并且是快速的。它由一条在质量和数量上与βAPP蛋白水解过程不同且完全独立于β-淀粉样前体蛋白的Aβ产生途径驱动,导致Aβ在细胞内快速大量积累,进而导致显著的神经退行性变和有症状的AD。在这种模式下,一种AD的预防性治疗方法,一种AD“他汀类药物”,在第二阶段开始之前的任何时间启动都将是有效的。此外,有充分的理由相信,使用一种在第二阶段阻断不依赖βAPP的Aβ产生途径的药物,不仅有可能预防疾病,而且即使在早期AD症状已经出现时也能够阻止并逆转疾病。本研究提出了AD是一种快速疾病的概念,为AD特异性Aβ产生途径的存在提供了证据,描述了构成驱动阿尔茨海默病的引擎的细胞和分子过程,并解释了为什么非人类哺乳动物不易患AD以及为什么只有一部分人类会患这种疾病。它确定阿尔茨海默病可以通过即使在生命后期开始的治疗干预来预防,详细阐述了该疾病背后的强大机制,表明在不依赖βAPP的途径中产生的Aβ保留在细胞内,解释了为什么抑制β分泌酶(BACE)和Aβ免疫疗法在AD治疗中无效以及为什么细胞内保留的β-淀粉样蛋白可能是阿尔茨海默病中神经元死亡的主要因素,需要生成一种能够通过不依赖βAPP的途径产生Aβ的新型动物AD模型,提出了与先前针对βAPP蛋白水解途径的成分截然不同的治疗靶点,并为设计不仅可用于预防而且可用于治疗和逆转疾病早期阶段的药物提供了概念依据。