Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, USA.
Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, USA.
World Neurosurg. 2020 Jun;138:e819-e826. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2020.03.099. Epub 2020 Mar 28.
Improving the comprehension and communication of patient education materials could augment patient participation in shared clinical decision making. Inadequate healthcare-oriented educational resources for patients with a newly diagnosed complex disease, such as a cerebral aneurysm, can lead to an insufficient understanding of their ailment. As such, we hypothesized that a PowerPoint-style educational intervention with grade-conscious (i.e., sixth grade level) written material accompanied by visual graphics would help improve patient health literacy and satisfaction.
A randomized prospective pilot study was conducted during a 1-year period in 2018. Preclinic encounter knowledge assessment surveys were administered to 52 patients with brain aneurysms (newly diagnosed or during follow-up) presenting for their neurosurgery outpatient clinic visit. The patients were assigned to 1 of 2 cohorts, with 26 each in the educational intervention group and control group, using a quasi-randomization method of alternating the assigned group for each successive patient. At the conclusion of their clinic encounter, all the patients completed a postclinic encounter knowledge assessment and satisfaction survey. Differences in covariates such as gender distribution, age, and family history of aneurysms were analyzed between the control and intervention groups.
The overall study cohort had a high baseline knowledge about cerebral aneurysms with an average preclinic encounter score of 5.37 on the 7-question survey. The educational intervention resulted in an upward trend in the patient knowledge scores. No statistically significant difference was detected in the patient satisfaction scores between the intervention and control groups. However, most of the patients receiving the educational intervention reported that the educational material was easy to understand (95.7%), helpful (86.9%), and relevant (87%) to their clinic visit.
Overall, in the present prospective study, the use of a multimedia-based educational intervention resulted in an upward trend in knowledge without a statistically significant difference in patient satisfaction scores compared with the control patients. To better measure the effectiveness of multimedia-based patient education interventions, future studies should account for the patients' baseline education level, preexisting educational resources available to study patients, socioeconomic factors, and emotional state.
提高患者教育材料的理解和沟通能力可以增强患者参与共同临床决策的能力。对于新诊断出患有复杂疾病(如脑动脉瘤)的患者,缺乏面向医疗的教育资源可能导致他们对疾病的理解不足。因此,我们假设使用带有视觉图形的六级(即六年级水平)书面材料的 PowerPoint 式教育干预措施将有助于提高患者的健康素养和满意度。
这是一项在 2018 年为期 1 年的随机前瞻性试点研究。对 52 名前来神经外科门诊就诊的脑动脉瘤患者(新诊断或随访期间)进行了预诊所遇知识评估调查。患者被分为教育干预组和对照组两组,每组 26 人,采用交替分配的方法对每个连续患者进行分组。在诊所就诊结束时,所有患者都完成了诊所就诊后的知识评估和满意度调查。分析了对照组和干预组之间的性别分布、年龄和动脉瘤家族史等协变量的差异。
总体研究队列对脑动脉瘤有很高的基线知识,7 个问题的调查平均预诊所遇得分为 5.37。教育干预导致患者知识得分呈上升趋势。干预组和对照组患者的满意度评分无统计学差异。然而,大多数接受教育干预的患者表示教育材料易于理解(95.7%)、有帮助(86.9%)且与他们的就诊相关(87%)。
总体而言,在本前瞻性研究中,与对照组相比,使用基于多媒体的教育干预措施导致知识呈上升趋势,但患者满意度评分无统计学差异。为了更好地衡量基于多媒体的患者教育干预措施的效果,未来的研究应考虑患者的基线教育水平、可供研究患者使用的现有教育资源、社会经济因素和情绪状态。