College of Health and Human Services, Governors State University, University Park, IL.
Moor House Research and Training Institute, Moor House School & College, United Kingdom.
Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2020 Apr 7;51(2):226-246. doi: 10.1044/2019_LSHSS-19-00046.
Purpose This article summarizes the shared principles and evidence underpinning methods employed in the three sentence-level (syntactic) grammatical intervention approaches developed by the authors. We discuss associated clinical resources and map a way forward for clinically useful research in this area. Method We provide an overview of the principles and perspectives that are common across our three syntactic intervention approaches: MetaTaal (Zwitserlood, 2015; Zwitserlood, Wijnen, et al., 2015), the SHAPE CODING system (Ebbels, 2007; Ebbels et al., 2014, 2007), and Complex Sentence Intervention (Balthazar & Scott, 2017, 2018). A description of each approach provides examples and summarizes current evidence supporting effectiveness for children with developmental language disorder ranging in age from 5 to 16 years. We suggest promising directions for future research that will advance our understanding of effective practices and support more widespread adoption of syntactic interventions with school-age children. Conclusion In each approach to syntactic intervention, careful and detailed analysis of grammatical knowledge is used to support target selection. Intervention targets are explicitly described and presented systematically using multimodal representations within engaging and functional activities. Treatment stimuli are varied within a target pattern in order to maximize learning. Similar intervention intervals and intensities have been studied and proven clinically feasible and have produced measurable effects. We identify a need for more research evidence to maximize the effectiveness of our grammatical interventions, encompassing languages other than English, as well as practical clinical tools to guide target selection, measurement of outcomes, and decisions about how to tailor interventions to individual needs.
目的 本文总结了作者开发的三种基于句子层面(句法)的语法干预方法所共有的原则和证据。我们讨论了相关的临床资源,并为该领域具有临床应用价值的研究指明了方向。
方法 我们概述了我们三种句法干预方法(MetaTaal、SHAPE CODING 系统和复杂句干预)所共有的原则和观点。每个方法的描述都提供了示例,并总结了当前支持 5 至 16 岁发育性语言障碍儿童有效性的证据。我们提出了有前途的未来研究方向,这些研究将增进我们对有效实践的理解,并支持更广泛地采用语法干预措施来帮助学龄儿童。
结论 在每种语法干预方法中,都对语法知识进行了仔细和详细的分析,以支持目标选择。干预目标被明确描述,并通过在引人入胜且实用的活动中使用多模态表示来系统呈现。在目标模式内对治疗刺激进行多样化处理,以最大限度地提高学习效果。已经对相似的干预间隔和强度进行了研究,并证明其在临床中是可行的,且能产生可衡量的效果。我们需要更多的研究证据来最大化我们语法干预的效果,涵盖英语以外的其他语言,以及实用的临床工具来指导目标选择、评估结果以及决定如何根据个体需求调整干预措施。