Dynako Joseph, Owens Garrett W, Loder Randall T, Frimpong Tony, Gerena Rolando Gabriel, Hasnain Fawaz, Snyder Dayton, Freiman Serena, Hart Kyle, Kacena Melissa A, Whipple Elizabeth C
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, Mississippi, USA.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA.
Heliyon. 2020 Mar 31;6(3):e03698. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e03698. eCollection 2020 Mar.
Bibliometric studies are important to understand changes and improvement opportunities in academia. This study compared bibliometric trends for two major sports medicine/arthroscopy journals, the () and over the past 30 years. Trends over time and comparisons between both journals were noted for common bibliometric variables (number of authors, references, pages, citations, and corresponding author position) as well as author gender and continental origin. Appropriate statistical analyses were performed. A p < 0.001 was considered statistically significant. One representative year per decade was used. There were 814 manuscripts from and 650 from . For the number of manuscripts steadily increased from 86 in 1986 to 350 in 2016; for the number of manuscripts increased from 73 in 1985/1986, to 267 in 2006, but then dropped to 229 in 2016. There were significant increases in all bibliometric variables, except for the number of citations which decreased in . There were significant differences in manuscript region of origin by journal (p = 0.000002) had a greater percentage of manuscripts from Asia than (19.3% vs 11.5%) while had a greater percentage from North America (70.3% vs 59.2%); both journals had similar percentages from Europe (18.2% for and 21.6% for ). For the average percentage of female first authors was 13.3%, increasing from 4.7% in 1986 to 19.3% in 2016; the average percentage of female corresponding authors was 7.3%. For , the average percentage of female first authors was 8.1%, increasing from 2.8% in 1985/1986 to 15.7% in 2016 (p = 0.00007). In conclusion, and showed an increase in most variables analyzed. Although is climbing at a higher rate than for female authors, has an overall greater percentage of female authors.
文献计量学研究对于了解学术界的变化和改进机会非常重要。本研究比较了两本主要运动医学/关节镜杂志(《 》和《 》)在过去30年的文献计量趋势。记录了随着时间的推移以及两本杂志之间在常见文献计量变量(作者数量、参考文献数量、页数、引用次数和通讯作者职位)以及作者性别和大陆来源方面的趋势。进行了适当的统计分析。p < 0.001被认为具有统计学意义。每十年选取一个代表性年份。《 》有814篇手稿,《 》有650篇。对于《 》,手稿数量从1986年的86篇稳步增加到2016年的350篇;对于《 》,手稿数量从1985/1986年的73篇增加到2006年的267篇,但在2016年降至229篇。除了《 》的引用次数下降外,所有文献计量变量均有显著增加。两本杂志在手稿来源地区方面存在显著差异(p = 0.000002),《 》来自亚洲的手稿百分比高于《 》(19.3%对11.5%),而《 》来自北美的百分比更高(70.3%对59.2%);两本杂志来自欧洲的百分比相似(《 》为18.2%,《 》为21.6%)。对于《 》,女性第一作者的平均百分比为13.3%,从1986年的4.7%增加到2016年的19.3%;女性通讯作者的平均百分比为7.3%。对于《 》,女性第一作者的平均百分比为8.1%,从1985/1986年的2.8%增加到2016年的15.7%(p = 0.00007)。总之,《 》和《 》在分析的大多数变量上都有所增加。尽管《 》在女性作者方面的增长速度高于《 》,但《 》的女性作者总体百分比更高。