Lancaster Medical School, Lancaster University, Bailrigg, Lancaster, LA1 4YW, England.
Emergency Department, North Manchester General Hospital, Delaunays Road, Crumpsall, Manchester, M8 5RB, England.
BMC Med Educ. 2020 Apr 9;20(1):110. doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-01996-8.
The learning environment impacts many aspects of healthcare education, including student outcomes. Rather than being a single and fixed phenomenon, it is made up of multiple micro learning environments. The standard clinical learning environment measurement tools do not consider such diversity and may fail to adequately capture micro learning environments. Moreover, the existing tools are often long and may take a prohibitive amount of time to complete properly. This may have a negative impact on their usefulness in educational improvement strategies. In addition, there is no universal tool available which could be utilised across several healthcare student groups and placement settings.
To create an evidence-based measurement tool for assessing clinical micro learning environments across several healthcare profession student groups.
The measurement tool was developed through a step-wise approach: 1) literature review with iterative analysis of existing tools; 2) generation of new items via thematic analysis of student experiences; 3) a Delphi process involving healthcare educators; 4) piloting of the prototype; and 5) item reduction.
The literature review and experiential data from healthcare students resulted in 115 and 43 items respectively. These items were refined, leaving 75 items for the Delphi process, which produced a prototype with 57 items. This prototype was then completed by 257 students across the range of healthcare professions, with item reduction resulting in a 12-item tool.
This paper describes a mixed methods approach to developing a brief micro learning environment measurement tool. The generated tool can be used for measuring student perceptions of clinical environments across several healthcare professions. Further cross-cultural and cross-professional validation studies are needed to support widespread use, possibly through mobile application.
学习环境影响医疗教育的许多方面,包括学生的学习成果。它不是一个单一且固定的现象,而是由多个微观学习环境组成的。标准的临床学习环境测量工具并没有考虑到这种多样性,可能无法充分捕捉微观学习环境。此外,现有的工具通常较长,可能需要花费大量时间才能正确完成。这可能会对它们在教育改进策略中的有用性产生负面影响。此外,目前没有通用的工具可以在多个医疗保健学生群体和实习环境中使用。
创建一种基于证据的测量工具,用于评估多个医疗保健专业学生群体的临床微观学习环境。
该测量工具是通过逐步的方法开发的:1)通过对现有工具的迭代分析进行文献回顾;2)通过对学生经验的主题分析生成新的项目;3)涉及医疗保健教育者的 Delphi 流程;4)原型的试点;和 5)项目缩减。
文献回顾和医疗保健学生的体验数据分别产生了 115 项和 43 项。这些项目经过改进,为 Delphi 流程留下了 75 项,该流程生成了一个包含 57 项的原型。然后,该原型由来自各种医疗保健专业的 257 名学生完成,通过项目缩减得到了一个 12 项的工具。
本文描述了一种混合方法,用于开发一个简短的微观学习环境测量工具。该生成的工具可用于测量多个医疗保健专业学生对临床环境的感知。需要进行进一步的跨文化和跨专业验证研究,以支持广泛使用,可能通过移动应用程序实现。