Jones I S, Whitfield R A
Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Washington, D.C. 20037.
Accid Anal Prev. 1988 Dec;20(6):411-9. doi: 10.1016/0001-4575(88)90039-5.
The relationship between crashworthiness ratings produced by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's (NHTSA's) New Car Assessment Program (NCAP) and the risk of incapacitating injury or death for drivers who are involved in single-car, fixed-object, frontal collisions was examined. The results are based on 6,405 such crashes from the Motor Vehicle Traffic Accident file of the Texas Department of Highways and Public Transportation. The risk of injury was modeled using logistic regression taking into account the NCAP test results for each individual model of car and the intervening effects of car mass, age of the driver, restraint use, and crash severity. Three measures of anthropometric dummy response, Head Injury Criterion (HIC), Chest Deceleration (CD), and femur load were used to indicate vehicle crash test performance. The results show that there is a significant relationship between the results of the NCAP tests and the risk of serious injury or death in actual single-car frontal accidents. In terms of overall injury, chest deceleration was a better predictor than the Head Injury Criterion. For restrained drivers, crash severity, driver age, and chest deceleration were significant parameters for predicting risk of serious injury or death; the risk of injury decreased as chest deceleration decreased. The results were similar for unrestrained drivers although vehicle mass and femur load were also significant factors in the model. The risk of overall injury decreased as chest deceleration decreased but appeared to decrease as femur load increased.
研究了美国国家公路交通安全管理局(NHTSA)的新车评估计划(NCAP)给出的防撞性评级与单车、固定物体正面碰撞事故中驾驶员致残伤害或死亡风险之间的关系。结果基于得克萨斯州公路与公共运输部机动车交通事故档案中的6405起此类碰撞事故。考虑到每款汽车的NCAP测试结果以及汽车质量、驾驶员年龄、安全带使用情况和碰撞严重程度的干预影响,使用逻辑回归对伤害风险进行建模。使用人体测量假人响应的三项指标,即头部损伤准则(HIC)、胸部减速度(CD)和股骨负荷来表明车辆碰撞测试性能。结果表明,NCAP测试结果与实际单车正面事故中严重伤害或死亡风险之间存在显著关系。就总体伤害而言,胸部减速度比头部损伤准则是更好的预测指标。对于系安全带的驾驶员,碰撞严重程度、驾驶员年龄和胸部减速度是预测严重伤害或死亡风险的重要参数;随着胸部减速度降低,伤害风险也降低。对于未系安全带的驾驶员,结果类似,不过车辆质量和股骨负荷也是该模型中的重要因素。随着胸部减速度降低,总体伤害风险降低,但随着股骨负荷增加,总体伤害风险似乎也降低。