Department of Forest and Wildlife Ecology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1630 Linden Drive, 237 Russell Labs, Madison, WI, 53706, U.S.A.
Bioacoustics Research Program, Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Cornell University, 159 Sapsucker Woods Road, Ithaca, NY, 14850, U.S.A.
Conserv Biol. 2021 Feb;35(1):336-345. doi: 10.1111/cobi.13516. Epub 2020 Aug 20.
Recent bioacoustic advances have facilitated large-scale population monitoring for acoustically active species. Animal sounds, however, can of information that is underutilized in typical approaches to passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) that treat sounds simply as detections. We developed 3 methods of extracting additional ecological detail from acoustic data that are applicable to a broad range of acoustically active species. We conducted landscape-scale passive acoustic surveys of a declining owl species and an invasive congeneric competitor in California. We then used sex-specific vocalization frequency to inform multistate occupancy models; call rates at occupied sites to characterize interactions with interspecific competitors and assess habitat quality; and a flexible multivariate approach to differentiate individuals based on vocal characteristics. The multistate occupancy models yielded novel estimates of breeding status occupancy rates that were more robust to false detections and captured known habitat associations more consistently than single-state occupancy models agnostic to sex. Call rate was related to the presence of a competitor but not habitat quality and thus could constitute a useful behavioral metric for interactions that are challenging to detect in an occupancy framework. Quantifying multivariate distance between groups of vocalizations provided a novel quantitative means of discriminating individuals with ≥20 vocalizations and a flexible tool for balancing type I and II errors. Therefore, it appears possible to estimate site turnover and demographic rates, rather than just occupancy metrics, in PAM programs. Our methods can be applied individually or in concert and are likely generalizable to many acoustically active species. As such, they are opportunities to improve inferences from PAM data and thus benefit conservation.
近年来,生物声学的进步使得大规模的种群监测成为可能,适用于活跃物种。然而,动物的声音包含了大量在被动声学监测(PAM)中未被充分利用的信息,这些信息在典型的 PAM 方法中被简单地视为检测。我们开发了 3 种从声学数据中提取额外生态细节的方法,这些方法适用于广泛的活跃物种。我们在加利福尼亚州对一种数量减少的猫头鹰物种和一种入侵的同种竞争物种进行了景观尺度的被动声学调查。然后,我们使用性别特异性发声频率来为多状态占有模型提供信息;在有生物栖息的地点的鸣叫率来描述与种间竞争的相互作用,并评估栖息地质量;以及一种灵活的多元方法,根据发声特征来区分个体。多状态占有模型产生了新颖的繁殖状态占有率估计值,这些估计值对误报更稳健,并且比不考虑性别的单一状态占有模型更一致地捕捉到已知的栖息地关联。鸣叫率与竞争物种的存在有关,但与栖息地质量无关,因此,它可以成为一种有用的行为指标,用于在占有框架中难以检测到的相互作用。量化组间发声的多元距离提供了一种新颖的定量方法,可以区分具有≥20 个发声的个体,并且是一种灵活的工具,可以平衡 I 型和 II 型错误。因此,在 PAM 计划中似乎有可能估计站点的周转率和人口率,而不仅仅是占有度量。我们的方法可以单独或协同应用,并且很可能适用于许多活跃的物种。因此,它们为从 PAM 数据中进行推断提供了机会,并因此有益于保护。