Johansson Hanna, Freidle Malin, Ekman Urban, Schalling Ellika, Leavy Breiffni, Svenningsson Per, Hagströmer Maria, Franzén Erika
Department of Neurobiology, Care Sciences and Society, Division of Physiotherapy, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Medical Unit Occupational Therapy & Physiotherapy, Allied Health Professionals Function, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Parkinsons Dis. 2020 Mar 25;2020:2410863. doi: 10.1155/2020/2410863. eCollection 2020.
Recent studies indicate that exercise can induce neuroplastic changes in people with Parkinson's disease (PwPD). Reports of feasibility outcomes from existing pilot trials however are, of date, insufficient to enable replication by others in larger definitive trials.
To evaluate trial design for a definitive trial by exploring process and scientific feasibility.
The trial design was a parallel-group RCT pilot with a 1 : 1 allocation ratio to either HiBalance or an active control group (HiCommunication). Both groups received one-hour sessions twice weekly, plus home exercises weekly, for 10 weeks. Participants with mild-to-moderate Parkinson's disease (PD) were recruited via advertisement. Assessment included physical performance, structural and functional MRI, blood sampling, neuropsychological assessment, and speech/voice assessment. Process and scientific feasibility were monitored throughout the study. Process feasibility involved recruitment, participant acceptability of assessments and interventions, assessment procedures (focus on imaging, blood sampling, and dual-task gait analysis), and blinding procedures. Scientific feasibility involved trends in outcome response and safety during group training and home exercises. Data are presented in median, minimum, and maximum values. Changes from pre- to postintervention are reported descriptively.
Thirteen participants were included (4 women, mean age 69.7 years), with a recruitment rate of 31%. Attendance rates and follow-up questionnaires indicated that both groups were acceptable to participate. Image quality was acceptable; however, diplopia and/or sleepiness were observed in several participants during MRI. With regard to dual-task gait performance, there appeared to be a ceiling effect of the cognitive tasks with seven participants scoring all correct answers at pretest. Blinding of group allocation was successful for one assessor but was broken for half of participants for the other.
The overall trial design proved feasible to perform, but further strengthening ahead of the definitive RCT is recommended, specifically with respect to MRI setup, cognitive dual-tasks during gait, and blinding procedures. This trial is registered with NCT03213873.
近期研究表明,运动可在帕金森病患者(PwPD)中诱导神经可塑性变化。然而,现有初步试验的可行性结果报告已过时,不足以让其他人在更大规模的确定性试验中进行重复。
通过探索过程和科学可行性来评估确定性试验的试验设计。
试验设计为平行组随机对照试验(RCT)试点,分配比例为1∶1,分为高平衡组或积极对照组(高交流组)。两组均每周接受两次一小时的课程,外加每周一次家庭锻炼,为期10周。通过广告招募轻度至中度帕金森病(PD)患者。评估包括身体性能、结构和功能磁共振成像(MRI)、血液采样、神经心理学评估以及言语/声音评估。在整个研究过程中监测过程和科学可行性。过程可行性包括招募、参与者对评估和干预的接受度、评估程序(重点是成像、血液采样和双任务步态分析)以及盲法程序。科学可行性包括组内训练和家庭锻炼期间结果反应和安全性的趋势。数据以中位数、最小值和最大值表示。描述性报告干预前后的变化。
纳入13名参与者(4名女性,平均年龄69.7岁),招募率为31%。出勤率和随访问卷表明两组都可接受参与。图像质量可接受;然而,在MRI检查期间,几名参与者出现复视和/或嗜睡。关于双任务步态表现,认知任务似乎存在天花板效应,7名参与者在预测试中所有答案均正确。一名评估者成功实现了组分配的盲法,但另一名评估者对一半参与者的盲法被打破。
总体试验设计证明可行,但建议在确定性随机对照试验之前进一步加强,特别是在MRI设置、步态期间的认知双任务以及盲法程序方面。该试验已在ClinicalTrials.gov注册,注册号为NCT03213873。