Clever Katharina, Richter Cynthia, Meyer Gabriele
Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Medical Faculty, Institute of Health and Nursing Science, Halle (Saale), Germany.
GMS J Med Educ. 2020 Mar 16;37(2):Doc26. doi: 10.3205/zma001319. eCollection 2020.
Although criteria and recommendations for the successful integration of sex- and gender-sensitive aspects in medical teaching have already been published, only a few medical faculties in Germany have conducted the systematic integration of sex- and gender-sensitive medicine. The aim of this expert survey, therefore, was to describe the current approaches to the integration of sex- and gender-sensitive medicine in teaching in the sense of Good Practice. Between April and June 2018, guided interviews were conducted with nine experts in the field of sex- and gender-sensitive medicine. Each of the experts had had experience of implementing sex- and gender-sensitive medicine at their universities. The expert interviews were then evaluated by means of quality content analysis, and frequency analyses were carried out. Aspects of sex- and gender-sensitive medicine were integrated both longitudinally and selectively into the compulsory curriculum or elective fields of various medical, health and nursing science courses. In the opinion of the experts, medical studies should promote the students' gender sensitivity and in particular impart knowledge about the psychosocial and biological aspects of sex- and gender-related differences and sex- and gender-sensitive communication. For the methodological implementation of the integrated contents, didactic resources were partly adapted or developed. The players in the implementation process were confronted with various challenges, e.g. the involvement of the lecturers, the perception of sex- and gender-sensitive medicine as a women's theme as well as ensuring the sustainable integration of sex- and gender-sensitive medicine, which is also structurally anchored in the faculty. Aspects of the curricular integration (e.g. evidence-basing, relevance in examinations) and the structural anchoring (e.g. central organization, staff availability) were mentioned i.a. as being crucial for success. A combination of top-down and bottom-up processes, e.g. by involving the faculty management but also by supporting student initiatives, was described as conducive to success. The depicted approaches to the integration of sex- and gender-sensitive teaching contents give insight as to how sex- and gender-sensitive medicine can be integrated into the curricula. The interviews with the experts point to current themes related to sex- and gender-sensitive medicine and didactic resources. Moreover, it becomes clear which challenges are to be expected for the integration of sex- and gender-sensitive medicine in teaching and how these can be addressed. Particularly the involvement of the faculty's lecturers but also the sustainable integration and continual quality assurance of sex- and gender-sensitive contents present challenges of a crucial nature.
尽管已发布了关于在医学教学中成功融入性别敏感方面的标准和建议,但德国只有少数医学院校系统地整合了性别敏感医学。因此,本次专家调查的目的是描述当前以良好实践为导向的将性别敏感医学融入教学的方法。2018年4月至6月期间,对九位性别敏感医学领域的专家进行了指导性访谈。每位专家都在各自大学有实施性别敏感医学的经验。然后通过质量内容分析对专家访谈进行评估,并进行频率分析。性别敏感医学的各个方面被纵向和有选择地纳入各种医学、健康和护理科学课程的必修课程或选修领域。专家们认为,医学学习应提高学生的性别敏感度,尤其要传授有关性别相关差异的心理社会和生物学方面以及性别敏感沟通的知识。对于整合内容的方法实施,部分教学资源进行了调整或开发。实施过程中的相关人员面临着各种挑战,例如讲师的参与度、将性别敏感医学视为女性主题的认知,以及确保性别敏感医学的可持续整合(这在学院结构中也有规定)。课程整合的各个方面(如基于证据、考试相关性)和结构规定(如中央组织、人员配备)等被提及是成功的关键因素。自上而下和自下而上相结合的过程,例如通过学院管理层的参与以及支持学生倡议,被认为有助于取得成功。所描述的将性别敏感教学内容融入课程的方法,让人了解如何将性别敏感医学融入课程。与专家的访谈指出了与性别敏感医学和教学资源相关的当前主题。此外,很明显在教学中整合性别敏感医学预计会面临哪些挑战以及如何应对这些挑战。特别是学院讲师的参与度,以及性别敏感内容的可持续整合和持续质量保证构成了关键性质的挑战。