Centre for Global Public Health, Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada.
India Health Action Trust, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
J Glob Health. 2020 Jun;10(1):010418. doi: 10.7189/jogh.10.010418.
In 2001, India prioritized eight most socioeconomically disadvantaged states known as Empowered Action Group (EAG) states and in 2013, it prioritized 190 of the 718 as high priority districts (HPDs) to accelerate the decline in maternal and newborn mortality. This paper assesses whether the HPDs achieved a greater coverage of maternal and newborn health interventions than the non-HPDs and HPDs in EAG states achieved greater coverage than those in non-EAG states.
We used data from the Sample Registration System to assess rural neonatal mortality trends in EAG states and all India. We computed a co-coverage index based on seven maternal and newborn health interventions from the 2015/16 National Family Health Survey. Difference in differences (DID) analyses were used to examine the contribution of district prioritization, considering the HPDs and the illiterate as treatment groups and 2013 as the time cut-off for the pre- and post-treatment.
Neonatal mortality declined in rural India from 36 to 27 per 1000 live births during 2010-2016 at 4.5% per year. Four EAG states experienced faster rates of decline than the national rate. From 2013, the co-coverage index increased significantly more in the HPDs compared to non-HPDs (DID = 0.11, ≤ 0.005). The district prioritization effect on co-coverage was statistically significant in only EAG states (DID = 0.13, ≤ 0.05). The coverage gains for illiterate mothers were greater than for literate mothers, especially in the HPDs.
The district prioritization in India is associated with greater improvements in the coverage of maternal and newborn health services in EAG states and the HPDs, including reductions in inequalities within those states and districts. There are however still large gaps between states and districts and within districts by the mother's literacy status that need further prioritization to make progress towards the SDG targets by 2030.
2001 年,印度将八个在社会经济方面处境最为不利的邦列为重点邦(EAG),并于 2013 年又将 718 个区中的 190 个划为高度优先区(HPD),以加快降低孕产妇和新生儿死亡率。本文评估了 HPD 是否在孕产妇和新生儿健康干预措施方面的覆盖范围大于非 HPD,以及 EAG 邦的 HPD 是否比非 EAG 邦的覆盖范围更大。
我们使用来自样本登记系统的数据评估了 EAG 邦和全印度的农村新生儿死亡率趋势。我们根据 2015/16 年全国家庭健康调查中的 7 项孕产妇和新生儿健康干预措施计算了一个共同覆盖指数。我们采用差值差异分析(DID)来考察地区优先排序的贡献,将 HPD 和文盲作为治疗组,将 2013 年作为治疗前后的时间分界点。
2010-2016 年期间,印度农村地区的新生儿死亡率从每 1000 例活产 36 例下降到 27 例,每年下降 4.5%。四个 EAG 邦的下降速度快于全国平均水平。从 2013 年开始,HPD 地区的共同覆盖指数增长明显快于非 HPD 地区(DID=0.11,P≤0.005)。只有在 EAG 邦,地区优先排序对共同覆盖的影响才具有统计学意义(DID=0.13,P≤0.05)。文盲母亲的覆盖率增长大于识字母亲,尤其是在 HPD 地区。
印度的地区优先排序与 EAG 邦和 HPD 地区孕产妇和新生儿健康服务覆盖范围的更大改善相关,包括减少了这些邦和地区内部的不平等。然而,各州和各地区之间以及各地区内部仍存在巨大差距,按母亲的文化程度划分,需要进一步优先排序,才能在 2030 年实现可持续发展目标的目标。