Prevention, Treatment and Rehabilitation Section, Drug Prevention and Health Branch, Division of Operations, United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), Wagramer Strasse 5, A-1400, Vienna, Austria.
Department of Human Development and Family Studies Office, 2625 N Loop Dr Ste 500 Research Park 2, Ames, IA, 50010, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2020 May 7;20(1):634. doi: 10.1186/s12889-020-08701-w.
Children living in challenged humanitarian settings (including those in rural/underserved areas, the displaced, refugees, in conflict/post conflict situations) are at greater risk of mental health difficulties or behavioural problems, with caregivers acting as their main protective factors. While many family skills programmes exist, very few were developed for, or piloted in, low resource settings (settings with limited infrastructure, typical of humanitarian settings). We therefore designed a brief and light programme; the Strong Families (SF) programme, consisting of 5 h contact time over 3 weeks. We conducted a pilot study with the aim to test the feasibility of implementation, and a preliminary look at the effectiveness of SF, in improving child behaviour and family functioning in families living in Afghanistan.
We recruited female caregivers and children aged 8-12 years through schools and drug treatment centres in Afghanistan and enrolled them in the SF programme. Demographic data, emotional and behavioural difficulties of children and parental skills and family adjustment measures were collected from caregivers before, 2 and 6 weeks after the intervention. Outcome was assessed through the SDQ (Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire), assessing children's behavioural, emotional, and social issues, and PAFAS (Parenting and Family Adjustment Scales), measuring parenting practices and family functioning.
We enrolled 72 families in the programme with a 93.1% retention rate (n = 67) for data collection 6 weeks post intervention. Mean age of caregivers was 36.1 years, they had 3.8 children on average and 91.7% of them had experienced war/armed conflict in their past. The average total difficulty score of the SDQ (ranging from 0 to 40, with scores above 16 being indicative of high problems) of the 72 children reduced significantly, from 17.8 at pre-test to 12.9 at post-test and 10.6 at second follow-up, with no difference in gender and most noticeably amongst those with the highest scores at baseline. Likewise, PAFAS scores decreased significantly after the programme, again with caregivers with the highest scores at baseline improving most.
The implementation of a brief family skills programme was seemingly effective and feasible in a resource-limited setting and positively improved child mental health and parenting practices and family adjustment skills. These results suggest the value of such a programme and call for further validation through other methods of impact assessment and outcome evaluation.
ISRCTN76509384. Retrospectively registered on March 9, 2020.
生活在充满挑战的人道主义环境中的儿童(包括农村/服务不足地区、流离失所者、难民、冲突后/冲突地区的儿童)面临更大的心理健康困难或行为问题风险,照顾者是他们的主要保护因素。虽然有许多家庭技能方案,但很少有针对资源有限环境(典型的人道主义环境中基础设施有限的环境)开发或试点的方案。因此,我们设计了一个简短而轻松的方案;坚强家庭(SF)方案,由 3 周内 5 小时的接触时间组成。我们进行了一项试点研究,旨在测试实施的可行性,并初步探讨 SF 方案在改善阿富汗家庭中儿童行为和家庭功能方面的有效性。
我们通过阿富汗的学校和戒毒中心招募了女性照顾者和 8-12 岁的儿童,并让他们参加 SF 方案。在干预前、干预后 2 周和 6 周,从照顾者那里收集儿童的情绪和行为困难、父母技能和家庭适应措施的数据。通过 SDQ(优势与困难问卷)评估结果,该问卷评估儿童的行为、情绪和社交问题,以及 PAFAS(育儿和家庭适应量表),衡量育儿实践和家庭功能。
我们共为该方案招募了 72 个家庭,数据收集 6 周后的保留率为 93.1%(n=67)。照顾者的平均年龄为 36.1 岁,他们平均有 3.8 个孩子,其中 91.7%的人在过去经历过战争/武装冲突。72 名儿童的 SDQ 总分(范围为 0 到 40,得分高于 16 表示存在较高问题)显著降低,从基线时的 17.8 分降至干预后的 12.9 分和第二次随访时的 10.6 分,性别之间无差异,且基线时得分最高的儿童变化最显著。同样,PAFAS 评分在方案实施后也显著下降,基线时得分最高的照顾者改善最明显。
在资源有限的环境中实施简短的家庭技能方案似乎是有效和可行的,并且可以积极改善儿童的心理健康以及育儿实践和家庭适应技能。这些结果表明了该方案的价值,并呼吁通过其他影响评估和结果评估方法进一步验证。
ISRCTN76509384。于 2020 年 3 月 9 日进行回顾性注册。