WHO Collaborating Centre for Community Oral Health Programmes and Research, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
University of Texas Health Science Center, San Antonio, TX, USA.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2020 Aug;48(4):338-348. doi: 10.1111/cdoe.12538. Epub 2020 May 8.
The WHO World Health Assembly established in 2007 a Resolution (WHA60.17) on oral health, which called upon countries to ensure that public health actions for disease prevention and health promotion are established. The objective of the present survey undertaken 10 years later (2017-2018) was to measure the application of such programmes for key population age groups in low-, middle- and high-income countries.
Oral health focal points of ministries of health worldwide (n = 101) answered a structured questionnaire on existing national oral health systems and the actual public health activities. The response rate was 58.4%. The questionnaire was used to collect information about structural factors, country workforce, financial models, provision of preventive services and promotion for oral health, school health programmes, administration of fluoride, national oral health targets and oral health surveillance. The countries were classified by national income for analysis of data.
Coverage of population groups by primary oral health care and emergency care varied by national income. The gap between countries in delivery of preventive care was strong since low-income countries less often reported preventive activities than middle-income countries and particularly when compared to high-income countries. School oral health programmes were less frequent in low-income than other countries. Moreover, population methods of fluoridation and use of fluoridated toothpaste were unusual in low-income countries. Health education, mass communication and community events were often essential elements in health promotion. In disease prevention, many countries considered the link between oral health and general health conditions and intervention towards shared risk factors of NCDs. The health concern for the consumption of tobacco, unhealthy diet and sugars was particularly emphasized by high-income countries but less highlighted by low-income countries. Finally, while national oral health targets for children and surveillance systems were frequently reported by countries, similar systems for adolescents, adults and older people were rare.
The inequities between countries in oral disease prevention and health promotion were substantial. Limited financial resources for preventive care and health promotion; inadequate workforce for oral health, and insufficient coverage in primary health care were observed in low-resource countries. The results of the survey demonstrate the need for building effective oral health systems oriented towards oral disease prevention and health promotion.
世界卫生大会(WHO)于 2007 年制定了一项关于口腔健康的决议(WHA60.17),呼吁各国确保建立疾病预防和健康促进的公共卫生行动。本调查于 10 年后(2017-2018 年)进行,旨在衡量中、高收入国家关键年龄组人群的此类方案的应用情况。
全球各国卫生部的口腔健康焦点(n=101)回答了一份关于现有国家口腔卫生系统和实际公共卫生活动的结构化问卷。回应率为 58.4%。该问卷用于收集有关结构因素、国家劳动力、财务模式、提供预防服务和促进口腔健康、学校卫生计划、氟化物管理、国家口腔健康目标和口腔健康监测的信息。按国家收入对各国进行分类以分析数据。
初级口腔保健和急诊保健覆盖的人群群体因国家收入而异。提供预防保健方面的国家差距很大,因为低收入国家报告的预防活动比中等收入国家少,与高收入国家相比更是如此。与其他国家相比,低收入国家的学校口腔卫生计划较少。此外,在低收入国家,人群方法的氟化和使用含氟牙膏并不常见。健康教育、大众传播和社区活动通常是健康促进的重要组成部分。在疾病预防方面,许多国家认为口腔健康与一般健康状况之间存在联系,并针对非传染性疾病的共同危险因素进行干预。高收入国家特别强调了对烟草、不健康饮食和糖的消费的健康关注,但低收入国家则较少强调。最后,虽然各国经常报告儿童的国家口腔健康目标和监测系统,但针对青少年、成年人和老年人的类似系统则很少。
国家间在口腔疾病预防和健康促进方面的不平等现象相当严重。在资源匮乏的国家,预防保健和健康促进的财政资源有限,口腔卫生劳动力不足,初级卫生保健覆盖面不足。调查结果表明,需要建立以口腔疾病预防和健康促进为导向的有效口腔卫生系统。