Mwinyogle Aubrey A, Bhatt Astha, Ogbuagu Onyebuchi U, Dhillon Neer, Sill Anne, Kowdley Gopal C
From the *Saint Agnes Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland.
†Advent Health Hospital, Tampa, Florida.
Am Surg. 2020 Apr 1;86(4):324-333.
Overutilization of healthcare resources is a threat to long-term healthcare sustainability and patient outcomes. CT is a costly but efficient means of assessing abdominal pain; however, 97 per cent of ED physicians acknowledge its overutilization. This study sought to understand factors that influence ED providers' decision regarding CT use in the evaluation of abdominal pain. After evaluating a patient for acute abdominal pain, ED providers filled in a form in which the primary diagnosis and index of suspicion were recorded. Bivariate and multivariate analyses were used to identify predictors of outcomes. The CT scan utilization rate was 54.82 per cent. Whereas 34.11 per cent of CT scans were normal, 30 per cent yielded an acute abdominal pathology. Tenderness and rebound tenderness were positive predictors of high index of suspicion [odds ratio (OR) 2.09 and 2.54, respectively]. These variables were also predictive of obtaining a CT scan [OR 2.64 and 3.41, respectively]. Compared with whites, the index of suspicion was 26 per cent and 56 per cent less likely to be high when patients were black [OR 0.73] or Hispanic [OR 0.44] respectively. Blacks and Hispanics were less likely to have CT scans performed than whites [OR 0.58 and 0.48, respectively]. Leukocytosis significantly affected the index of suspicion for acute abdominal pathology, obtaining a CT scan and the acuity of CT scan diagnosis on multivariate analysis. Patients aged ≥60 years had 2.03 odds of acute CT finding compared with those aged <60 years. There is a need for committed efforts to optimize CT scan utilization and eliminate socioeconomic disparities in health care.
医疗资源的过度使用对长期医疗可持续性和患者治疗结果构成威胁。CT是评估腹痛的一种昂贵但有效的手段;然而,97%的急诊科医生承认其存在过度使用的情况。本研究旨在了解影响急诊科医护人员在评估腹痛时使用CT的决策因素。在对一名急性腹痛患者进行评估后,急诊科医护人员填写一份记录初步诊断和怀疑指数的表格。采用双变量和多变量分析来确定结果的预测因素。CT扫描利用率为54.82%。虽然34.11%的CT扫描结果正常,但30%显示有急性腹部病变。压痛和反跳痛是高怀疑指数的阳性预测因素[比值比(OR)分别为2.09和2.54]。这些变量也是进行CT扫描的预测因素[OR分别为2.64和3.41]。与白人相比,当患者为黑人[OR 0.73]或西班牙裔[OR 0.44]时,高怀疑指数的可能性分别降低26%和56%。黑人和西班牙裔接受CT扫描的可能性低于白人[OR分别为0.58和0.48]。在多变量分析中,白细胞增多症显著影响急性腹部病变的怀疑指数、进行CT扫描以及CT扫描诊断的敏锐度。≥60岁的患者与<60岁的患者相比,急性CT检查发现的几率为2.03。有必要做出坚定努力来优化CT扫描的使用,并消除医疗保健中的社会经济差异。