Department of Chemistry, Rice University, Houston, Texas 77005, United States.
Department of Physics, Rice University, Houston, Texas 77005, United States.
J Chem Theory Comput. 2020 Jun 9;16(6):3977-3988. doi: 10.1021/acs.jctc.0c00188. Epub 2020 May 22.
Recently several techniques have emerged that significantly enhance the quality of predictions of protein tertiary structures. In this study, we describe the performance of AWSEM-Suite, an algorithm that incorporates template-based modeling and coevolutionary restraints with a realistic coarse-grained force field, AWSEM. With its roots in neural networks, AWSEM contains both physical and bioinformatical energies that have been optimized using energy landscape theory. AWSEM-Suite participated in CASP13 as a server predictor and generated reliable predictions for most targets. AWSEM-Suite ranked eighth in both the free-modeling category and the hard-to-model category and in one case provided the best submitted prediction. Here we critically discuss the prediction performance of AWSEM-Suite using several examples from different categories in CASP13. Structure prediction tests on these selected targets, two of them being hard-to-model targets, show that AWSEM-Suite can achieve high-resolution structure prediction after incorporating both template guidances and coevolutionary restraints even when homology is weak. For targets with reliable templates (template-easy category), introducing coevolutionary restraints sometimes damages the overall quality of the predictions. Free energy profile analyses demonstrate, however, that the incorporations of both of these evolutionarily informed terms effectively increase the funneling of the landscape toward native-like structures while still allowing sufficient flexibility to correct for discrepancies between the correct target structure and the provided guidance. In contrast to other predictors that are exclusively oriented toward structure prediction, the connection of AWSEM-Suite to a statistical mechanical basis and affiliated molecular dynamics and importance sampling simulations makes it suitable for functional explorations.
最近出现了几种技术,可显著提高蛋白质三级结构预测的质量。在本研究中,我们描述了 AWSEM-Suite 的性能,该算法将基于模板的建模和共进化约束与现实的粗粒度力场 AWSEM 相结合。AWSEM 基于神经网络,包含经过能量景观理论优化的物理和生物信息学能量。AWSEM-Suite 作为服务器预测器参加了 CASP13,并为大多数目标生成了可靠的预测。AWSEM-Suite 在自由建模类别和硬建模类别中均排名第八,在一种情况下提供了最佳提交预测。在这里,我们使用 CASP13 中的几个示例从几个方面对 AWSEM-Suite 的预测性能进行了批判性讨论。对这些选定目标的结构预测测试,其中两个是硬建模目标,表明 AWSEM-Suite 可以在整合模板指导和共进化约束后实现高分辨率的结构预测,即使同源性较弱也是如此。对于具有可靠模板的目标(模板简单类别),引入共进化约束有时会损害预测的整体质量。自由能谱分析表明,引入这两个进化信息术语可以有效地增加景观向天然样结构的漏斗效应,同时仍允许足够的灵活性来纠正正确目标结构和提供的指导之间的差异。与其他专门面向结构预测的预测器不同,AWSEM-Suite 与统计力学基础以及相关的分子动力学和重要性抽样模拟的连接使其适合功能探索。