Keith S N, Bell R M, Williams A P
J Natl Med Assoc. 1988 Feb;80(2):153-8.
During the decade of the 1970s, affirmative action programs were introduced in US medical schools for the purpose of increasing the number of black and other minority medical students and of improving the medical care resources for black and other minority communities. Having for many years served as the main sources of black physicians in the US, Howard University College of Medicine and Meharry Medical College School of Medicine were also affected by affirmative action. No previous studies have compared the black graduates from Howard and Meharry with black and other minority graduates from the other US medical schools.The purpose of this study was to compare these medical school graduates in terms of actual choice of specialty, patient characteristics, practice location, and specialty board certification, using the graduating class of 1975. A greater proportion of black graduates from Howard and Meharry chose primary care specialties than did black graduates from other schools, though this difference was not statistically significant. Black graduates from Howard and Meharry had significantly greater proportions of black patients compared with black graduates from other schools, but the same proportion of Medicaid patients.Though not statistically significant, black graduates from Howard and Meharry were less likely to be found practicing in federally designated underserved areas. Black graduates from Meharry were significantly less likely to have achieved specialty board certification, compared with graduates from Howard or the other medical schools. These results illustrate the experience of Howard and Meharry during the era of affirmative action and generally support their critically important role in producing black physicians and enhancing medical care resources in the black community.
在20世纪70年代的十年间,美国医学院引入了平权行动计划,目的是增加黑人及其他少数族裔医学生的数量,并改善黑人及其他少数族裔社区的医疗资源。作为美国黑人医生的主要来源已有多年的霍华德大学医学院和梅哈里医学院也受到了平权行动的影响。此前没有研究将霍华德大学和梅哈里医学院的黑人毕业生与美国其他医学院的黑人和其他少数族裔毕业生进行比较。本研究的目的是利用1975届毕业生,在实际专业选择、患者特征、执业地点和专业委员会认证方面对这些医学院的毕业生进行比较。与其他学校的黑人毕业生相比,霍华德大学和梅哈里医学院的黑人毕业生选择初级保健专业的比例更高,不过这一差异在统计学上并不显著。与其他学校的黑人毕业生相比,霍华德大学和梅哈里医学院的黑人毕业生的黑人患者比例显著更高,但医疗补助患者的比例相同。虽然在统计学上不显著,但霍华德大学和梅哈里医学院毕业的黑人医生在联邦指定的医疗服务不足地区执业的可能性较小。与霍华德大学或其他医学院的毕业生相比,梅哈里医学院的黑人毕业生获得专业委员会认证的可能性显著更低。这些结果说明了霍华德大学和梅哈里医学院在平权行动时代的经历,并总体上支持了它们在培养黑人医生和加强黑人社区医疗资源方面的至关重要的作用。