Dekker Anne-Britt E, Kleiss Iris, Batra Nikita, Seghers Matthew, Schipper Inger B, Ring David, Claborn Kasey
Dell Medical School Austin - The University of Texas at Austin, TX, USA.
Leiden University Medical Center, the Netherlands.
J Orthop. 2020 Apr 29;22:184-189. doi: 10.1016/j.jor.2020.04.016. eCollection 2020 Nov-Dec.
Strategies for pain alleviation have relied heavily on opioids in the recent decades. One consequence is a crisis of opioid misuse, overdose, and overdose related death. This study sought patient and clinician incentives and barriers to the use of opioids in musculoskeletal illness.
In this qualitative study, twenty-eight patients and eight clinicians participated in a semi-structured interview seeking incentives and barriers for opioid use and prescription in musculoskeletal illness. Interviews were conducted by a trained qualitative interviewer. The interview data were transcribed and analyzed using a thematic analysis framework.
Patient incentives for opioid use included doctor's orders, opioids being the only effective way to alleviate pain, alleviating symptoms of depression and anxiety, being able to keep a job, and lower cost of opioids relative to alternative treatment options. Patient barriers included associated risks (side effects, addiction) and wanting to control pain intensity. Clinician incentives for prescribing opioids included adequate pain alleviation, patient satisfaction, relatively inexpensive costs of opioids, convenience and doing what was taught by the clinician's superior. Lacking time and resources to adequately inform patients on appropriate opioid use and alternative treatments, likely results in more opioid prescribing than arguably necessary. Barriers for opioid prescribing included specific patient characteristics (psychiatric background, history of opioid misuse) and illness characteristics (nature of the injury, medical contra-indications).
Patients feel that opioids should be used with caution. Clinicians in this study reported a tendency to default to opioids out of habit and convenience. Both patients and clinicians were aware that opioids are often misused to treat emotional pain.
近几十年来,缓解疼痛的策略严重依赖阿片类药物。一个后果是阿片类药物滥用、过量使用及过量使用相关死亡的危机。本研究探寻了患者和临床医生在肌肉骨骼疾病中使用阿片类药物的激励因素和障碍。
在这项定性研究中,28名患者和8名临床医生参与了半结构化访谈,以探寻肌肉骨骼疾病中使用和开具阿片类药物的激励因素和障碍。访谈由一名经过培训的定性访谈员进行。访谈数据经转录后使用主题分析框架进行分析。
患者使用阿片类药物的激励因素包括医嘱、阿片类药物是缓解疼痛的唯一有效方法、缓解抑郁和焦虑症状、能够保住工作以及相对于替代治疗方案阿片类药物成本较低。患者的障碍包括相关风险(副作用、成瘾)以及想要控制疼痛强度。临床医生开具阿片类药物的激励因素包括充分缓解疼痛、患者满意度、阿片类药物成本相对较低、便利性以及按照上级教导行事。缺乏时间和资源向患者充分告知阿片类药物的正确使用方法和替代治疗方案,可能导致开具的阿片类药物比合理需要的更多。开具阿片类药物的障碍包括特定的患者特征(精神病史、阿片类药物滥用史)和疾病特征(损伤性质、医学禁忌)。
患者认为应谨慎使用阿片类药物。本研究中的临床医生报告称,出于习惯和便利性,他们倾向于默认使用阿片类药物。患者和临床医生都意识到阿片类药物经常被滥用来治疗情绪疼痛。