Department of Neurosurgery, University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
Department of Neurosurgery, University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
World Neurosurg. 2020 Aug;140:251-257. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2020.05.100. Epub 2020 May 17.
Although the historical relationships between William Osler, Harvey Williams Cushing, and William Perine Van Wagenen are well known in the neurosurgical world, the nature of the mentor-mentee relationships that existed between these historical giants is not widely appreciated. In this historical vignette, we describe and exemplify such relationships, while at the same time extract important and applicable principles from them. We reviewed relevant primary and secondary sources that documented the interactions between Cushing, Osler, and Van Wagenen. In founding the field of neurological surgery, the brilliant yet volatile Dr. Harvey Cushing received guidance from his mentor, Dr. William Osler. Through our review, it is undeniable that Dr. Osler's personal and professional guidance was vital to young Dr. Cushing's success as the founder of modern neurosurgery. Likewise, Cushing's tutelage of Van Wagenen enabled Van Wagenen to become a leader of a second generation of neurosurgeons, thereby perpetuating the existence of Cushing's high neurosurgical standards. These historical mentor-mentee relationships were built on 4 primary components: accurate recognition of talent, guidance, arrangement of opportunity, and sustenance of mentorship-actions that are commonly implicated in effective mentorship in contemporary studies. Proper mentorship remains indispensable for the success of neurosurgical trainees.
虽然威廉·奥斯勒 (William Osler)、哈维·威廉姆斯·库欣 (Harvey Williams Cushing) 和威廉·佩里内·范瓦根宁恩 (William Perine Van Wagenen) 之间的历史关系在神经外科学界广为人知,但这些历史巨人之间存在的导师-学员关系的性质并不为大众所理解。在这个历史小插曲中,我们描述并举例说明了这些关系,同时从中提取出重要且适用的原则。我们查阅了记录库欣、奥斯勒和范瓦根宁恩之间互动的相关原始资料和二手资料。在开创神经外科学领域时,才华横溢但脾气暴躁的哈维·库欣博士 (Dr. Harvey Cushing) 从他的导师威廉·奥斯勒博士 (Dr. William Osler) 那里获得了指导。通过我们的回顾,可以肯定地说,奥斯勒博士的个人和专业指导对年轻的库欣博士作为现代神经外科学的奠基人取得成功至关重要。同样,库欣对范瓦根宁恩的指导使范瓦根宁恩成为第二代神经外科医生的领袖,从而使库欣的高标准神经外科学得以延续。这些历史上的导师-学员关系建立在以下 4 个主要因素之上:准确识别人才、指导、提供机会和维持指导关系——这些都是当代研究中有效指导的常见因素。适当的指导对于神经外科受训者的成功仍然是不可或缺的。