Kaur Gurleen, Rehncy Jagdeep, Kahal Karamdeep Singh, Singh Jaspreet, Sharma Vidushi, Matreja Prithpal Singh, Grewal Harmandeep
Department of Pharmacology, Adesh Medical College & Hospital, Kurukshetra, India.
Department of Orthopaedics, Government Medical College, Patiala, India.
J Med Educ Curric Dev. 2020 May 13;7:2382120520920640. doi: 10.1177/2382120520920640. eCollection 2020 Jan-Dec.
The need for case-based learning in basic subjects is being recognized world over. Early clinical illustrations and actual clinical exposure enable students to associate basic science and real patient situations, probably increasing their retention of knowledge. The study was conducted to introduce an alternate method of teaching-learning in pharmacology in a large classroom setting to integrate pharmacology into clinical setting for better learning and understanding of the subject.
Ninety-four students of second professional MBBS of a medical college in Punjab were divided into 2 groups and were taught a 2-hour topic in pharmacology using case-based learning (CBL) method and didactic lecture (DL) method using a crossover design. Their attendance and written test score at the end of teaching session were compared. Feedback from students and faculty was taken by prestructured questionnaires.
There was an increase in students' attendance ( = .008) in CBL sessions but insignificant difference in their performance ( = .98) in the tests. Most (84%) of the students felt that CBL is a better method of teaching-learning than traditional DL. The teaching faculty felt that the students looked more interested and were themselves more motivated for the newer method of teaching.
Case-based learning led to improvement in student motivation, satisfaction, and engagement. Most students and faculty accepted that CBL was an effective learning tool for pharmacology teaching in a large group setting and supported the incorporation of CBL into traditional DL teaching.
基础学科中基于案例的学习需求在全球范围内都得到了认可。早期的临床实例和实际临床接触能使学生将基础科学与真实患者情况联系起来,可能会增强他们对知识的记忆。本研究旨在引入一种在大课堂环境下药理学教学的替代方法,将药理学融入临床情境,以便更好地学习和理解该学科。
旁遮普一所医学院的94名医学学士二年级学生被分为两组,采用交叉设计,分别使用基于案例的学习(CBL)方法和讲授式教学(DL)方法教授药理学中一个两小时的主题。比较了他们在教学课程结束时的出勤情况和笔试成绩。通过预先设计的问卷收集学生和教师的反馈。
CBL课程中学生的出勤率有所提高(=0.008),但他们在测试中的表现差异不显著(=0.98)。大多数(84%)学生认为CBL是比传统讲授式教学更好的教学方法。教师们认为学生对这种新的教学方法看起来更感兴趣,积极性也更高。
基于案例的学习提高了学生的积极性、满意度和参与度。大多数学生和教师都认为CBL是大课堂环境下药理学教学的有效学习工具,并支持将CBL纳入传统讲授式教学中。