Department of Sociology and Jacobs Center for Productive Youth Development, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Swiss Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training (SFIVET), Zollikofen, Berne, Switzerland.
J Youth Adolesc. 2021 Mar;50(3):391-407. doi: 10.1007/s10964-020-01257-3. Epub 2020 May 23.
In tracked and highly stratified educational systems, where educational reproduction is particularly strong, the chances of students to achieve more education than their parents did are truncated. Little is known, however, what may help students raised in lower-educated families to become upwardly mobile at the transition to upper-secondary education. In tracked educational systems, this transition is decisive for ultimate educational attainment across the life course. The study addresses this research gap by examining whether quality of social relationships (i.e., social capital) among students, parents, and teachers matters for student and teacher assessment of students' agentic capabilities (i.e., work habits) at age 15. If so, the question is whether these assessments help students become enrolled in high-status upper-secondary school tracks at age 18, thus achieving educational upward mobility. The analyses are based on 401 students from two cohorts in the German- and French-speaking parts of Switzerland, interviewed at the ages of 15 (T1) and 18 (T2) (60.35% females, M = 15.2, SD = 0.2; 58.35% older cohort), including data collected by questionnaire from primary caregivers and teachers at student age of 15. The students come from families where highest parental education attainment is below the high-status academic or vocational baccalaureate in upper-secondary education. They may thus experience the opportunity to gain access to these high-status tracks at the transition to upper-secondary education. A structural equation model reveals the role of student assessment of their agentic capabilities and teacher assessment of these competencies in mediating the relation of social capital accrued at home and at school to educational upward mobility. This novel evidence on mechanisms of social advancement may be prone to inform interventions helping students from less-educated families to succeed in tracked and stratified educational systems.
在具有明显阶层分化和严格分流的教育体制中,教育再生产作用极强,学生接受比父母更高等的教育的机会受到严重限制。然而,对于出身于低学历家庭的学生,在进入高中阶段时,哪些因素有助于他们实现向上流动,我们知之甚少。在具有明显阶层分化和严格分流的教育体制中,这一过渡对学生整个求学生涯的最终教育成就具有决定性影响。本研究通过考察学生、家长和教师之间的社会关系质量(即社会资本)是否对学生在 15 岁时的自主能力(即学习习惯)的学生和教师评估产生影响,来填补这一研究空白。如果有影响,那么问题是这些评估是否有助于学生在 18 岁时进入高地位的高中阶段,从而实现教育向上流动。本研究基于瑞士德语区和法语区的两个队列的 401 名学生,在他们 15 岁(T1)和 18 岁(T2)时进行了访谈(女性占 60.35%,M=15.2,SD=0.2;年长队列占 58.35%),包括通过问卷收集的学生 15 岁时主要照顾者和教师的数据。这些学生来自于父母最高学历低于高中阶段高地位的学术或职业学士学位的家庭。因此,他们在进入高中阶段时可能有机会获得这些高地位的学习途径。结构方程模型揭示了学生对自身自主能力的评估以及教师对这些能力的评估在家庭和学校获得的社会资本与教育向上流动之间的关系中的中介作用。这些关于社会进步机制的新证据可能有助于为帮助来自低学历家庭的学生在具有明显阶层分化和严格分流的教育体制中取得成功的干预措施提供信息。