Mele Francesca, Buchmann Marlis, Burger Kaspar
Jacobs Center for Productive Youth Development, University of Zurich, Andreasstrasse 15, 8050, Zurich, Switzerland.
Department of Sociology, University of Zurich, Andreasstrasse 15, 8050, Zurich, Switzerland.
J Youth Adolesc. 2023 Dec;52(12):2620-2635. doi: 10.1007/s10964-023-01846-y. Epub 2023 Sep 2.
Little is known about the role of agency in transitions in tracked education systems or whether it varies by socioeconomic background. This study addressed this gap by estimating structural equation models based on longitudinal data that are representative of the German- and French-speaking parts of Switzerland (N = 1273 individuals, surveyed from age 6 to 18, mean age at wave 1: M = 6.54, SD = 0.50, female = 49%). The findings reveal that agency (captured by study effort and occupational aspirations) and socioeconomic background (measured by parental education and family income) significantly predicted students' transitions to academically demanding tracks in lower- and upper-secondary education. In the transition to upper-secondary education, students with fewer socioeconomic resources benefitted less than their more advantaged peers from ambitious aspirations, but they benefitted more from exerting effort. These findings suggest that both an optimistic forward-looking orientation and the exertion of effort are required to make it to an academic track. Effort may serve as a "substitutive" resource for less socioeconomically advantaged students, whereas ambitious aspirations may enhance the positive effect of family socioeconomic resources on academic educational trajectories. Overall, the evidence from this study calls for greater attention to investigating not only how agency shapes adolescents' educational trajectories and opportunities but also how its role differs across social groups.
在有升学轨迹的教育体系中,关于能动性的作用,或者它是否因社会经济背景而异,人们所知甚少。本研究通过基于纵向数据估计结构方程模型填补了这一空白,这些数据代表了瑞士德语区和法语区(N = 1273人,从6岁到18岁接受调查,第1轮调查时的平均年龄:M = 6.54,标准差 = 0.50,女性占49%)。研究结果表明,能动性(通过学习努力程度和职业抱负来衡量)和社会经济背景(通过父母教育程度和家庭收入来衡量)显著预测了学生在初中和高中阶段向学术要求较高的升学轨迹的转变。在向高中教育的过渡中,社会经济资源较少的学生相比条件更优越的同龄人,从远大抱负中获益更少,但他们从努力学习中获益更多。这些发现表明,要进入学术轨道,既需要乐观的前瞻性取向,也需要付出努力。努力可能是社会经济条件较差的学生的一种“替代”资源,而远大抱负可能会增强家庭社会经济资源对学术教育轨迹的积极影响。总体而言,本研究的证据呼吁人们更加关注不仅要研究能动性如何塑造青少年的教育轨迹和机会以及其作用在不同社会群体中如何不同。