School of Physiotherapy and Exercise Science, Curtin University, GPO Box U1987, Perth, WA, 6845, Australia.
Monash Rural Health Churchill, Monash University, Northways Road, Churchill, VIC, 3842, Australia.
Int Breastfeed J. 2020 May 24;15(1):48. doi: 10.1186/s13006-020-00294-9.
Differences in physiotherapy intervention practices for mastitis have been shown across Australian regions and facilities and it is unknown if this is associated with physiotherapists' definition and diagnosis of Inflammatory Conditions of the Lactating Breast (ICLB). The aims were to determine how Australian physiotherapists' define and diagnose ICLB and if there are regional or facility differences in their ICLB definition and diagnosis.
A cross-sectional mixed methods design was used to investigate how physiotherapists construct a definition and diagnosis of ICLB, via online qualitative and quantitative questions. Participants included 63 Australian physiotherapists who treated at least one woman with ICLB per month, over the last year. Thematic analysis and descriptive statistics were used to analyse qualitative and quantitative responses, respectively.
ICLB definition varied among physiotherapists (n = 63) with generated themes including definitions based on pathophysiology (57%), combination of local and systemic symptoms (38%), conditions (32%), local symptoms (25%) and breast function (16%). Overall, quantitative data supported these findings, as some physiotherapists considered blocked ducts an ICLB (83%), but some did not (17%), and some considered abscess and engorgement an ICLB (65%) and some did not (35%). For ICLB diagnosis, the main theme generated was lack of consensus between physiotherapists (n = 39) on the number or combination of local or systemic symptoms required. Quantitative data confirmed these themes, as 63% of physiotherapists (n = 63) indicated that more than one symptom was necessary to clinically diagnose ICLB, but 27% required only one symptom. For region and type of facility, consistency across the themes for region and facility was evident. Overall, quantitative data confirmed these findings, with no regional or facility differences, except physiotherapists from the Australian state of Victoria (96%) were more likely to consider blocked ducts as an ICLB, compared to those from the states of NSW (71%) or WA (71%) (n = 58; χ = 6.49, p = 0.04).
Australian physiotherapists have varied definitions of ICLB and the required ICLB symptoms for clinical diagnosis. These results may prompt physiotherapists, who treat ICLB, to engage in explicit communication when discussing an ICLB in patient care, when delivering information in training courses and in developing treatment guidelines.
在澳大利亚的不同地区和医疗机构中,针对乳腺炎的物理治疗干预措施存在差异,而这是否与物理治疗师对哺乳期乳腺炎性疾病(ICLB)的定义和诊断有关尚不清楚。本研究旨在确定澳大利亚的物理治疗师如何定义和诊断 ICLB,以及他们在 ICLB 的定义和诊断上是否存在地区或机构差异。
采用横断面混合方法设计,通过在线定性和定量问题来调查物理治疗师如何构建 ICLB 的定义和诊断。参与者包括 63 名澳大利亚物理治疗师,他们在过去一年中每月至少治疗一名患有 ICLB 的女性。使用主题分析和描述性统计分别对定性和定量数据进行分析。
ICLB 的定义在物理治疗师中存在差异(n=63),生成的主题包括基于病理生理学的定义(57%)、局部和全身症状的组合(38%)、疾病(32%)、局部症状(25%)和乳房功能(16%)。总体而言,定量数据支持了这些发现,因为一些物理治疗师认为乳腺管堵塞是 ICLB(83%),但也有一些不这样认为(17%),还有一些物理治疗师认为脓肿和肿胀是 ICLB(65%),但也有一些不这样认为(35%)。对于 ICLB 的诊断,生成的主要主题是物理治疗师之间缺乏共识(n=39),即需要多少或哪种局部或全身症状的组合才能进行临床诊断。定量数据证实了这些主题,因为 63%的物理治疗师(n=63)表示需要不止一种症状才能临床诊断 ICLB,但 27%的物理治疗师只需一种症状。对于地区和机构类型,地区和机构之间的主题一致性明显。总体而言,定量数据证实了这些发现,除了维多利亚州(96%)的物理治疗师比新南威尔士州(71%)或西澳大利亚州(71%)的物理治疗师(n=58;χ²=6.49,p=0.04)更有可能认为乳腺管堵塞是 ICLB 外,没有地区或机构差异。
澳大利亚的物理治疗师对 ICLB 有不同的定义,以及进行临床诊断所需的 ICLB 症状。这些结果可能会促使治疗 ICLB 的物理治疗师在患者护理中讨论 ICLB 时、在培训课程中提供信息时以及在制定治疗指南时进行明确的沟通。