Radiation Epidemiology Branch, Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics, National Cancer Institute, NIH, DHHS, Rockville, Maryland.
Division of Environmental Epidemiology, Institute for Risk Assessment Sciences, Utrecht University, Utrecht, the Netherlands.
Am J Ind Med. 2020 Sep;63(9):741-754. doi: 10.1002/ajim.23142. Epub 2020 May 31.
While international agreement supports a causal relationship of benzene exposure with acute myeloid leukemia, there is debate about benzene and lymphoid neoplasm risks.
In a case-cohort study with follow-up of 110 631 Chinese workers during 1972-1999, we evaluated benzene exposure-response for non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL), lymphoid leukemias (LL), acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL), and total lymphoid neoplasms (LN). We estimated benzene exposures using state-of-the-art hierarchical modeling of occupational factors calibrated with historical routine measurements and evaluated cumulative exposure-response using Cox regression.
NHL and other specified LN were increased in exposed vs unexposed workers. However, there was no evidence of exposure-response for NHL or other specified LN. Based on a linear exposure-response, relative risks at 100 parts per million-years (RR at 100 ppm-years) for cumulative benzene exposure using a 2-year lag (exposure at least 2 years before the time at risk) were 1.05 for NHL (95 percent confidence interval (CI) = 0.97, 1.27; 32 cases), 1.11 for LL (95% CI < 0, 1.66; 12 cases), 1.21 for ALL (95% CI < 0, 3.53; 10 cases), and 1.02 for total LN (95% CI < 0, 1.16; 49 cases). No statistically significant exposure-response trends were apparent for these LN for 2 to <10-year or ≥10-year lags. NHL risks were not significantly modified by sex, age, or year at first exposure, attained age, or time since exposure.
Given the study strengths and limitations, we found little evidence of exposure-response for benzene and NHL, LL, ALL, or total LN, although NHL and other specified LN were increased in exposed vs unexposed individuals.
虽然国际协议支持苯暴露与急性髓系白血病之间存在因果关系,但对于苯与淋巴肿瘤风险之间的关系仍存在争议。
在一项病例-对照研究中,我们对 1972 年至 1999 年期间随访的 110631 名中国工人进行了研究,评估了苯暴露与非霍奇金淋巴瘤(NHL)、淋巴白血病(LL)、急性淋巴细胞白血病(ALL)和总淋巴肿瘤(LN)之间的关系。我们使用职业因素的最新层次建模来估计苯暴露情况,该模型通过历史常规测量进行校准,并使用 Cox 回归评估累积暴露-反应关系。
暴露组工人的 NHL 和其他特指 LN 的发病率高于未暴露组工人。然而,没有证据表明 NHL 或其他特指 LN 与苯暴露之间存在暴露-反应关系。基于线性暴露-反应,在使用 2 年滞后(至少在风险期前 2 年有暴露)的情况下,累积苯暴露 100 百万年(RR 在 100ppm-年)的相对风险(RR 在 100ppm-年)为 NHL 为 1.05(95%置信区间(CI)=0.97,1.27;32 例),LL 为 1.11(95%CI <0,1.66;12 例),ALL 为 1.21(95%CI <0,3.53;10 例),总 LN 为 1.02(95%CI <0,1.16;49 例)。对于 2 至<10 年或≥10 年的滞后时间,这些 LN 均未显示出明显的暴露-反应趋势。NHL 风险与性别、年龄或首次暴露的年份、实际年龄或暴露后时间无显著相关性。
考虑到研究的优势和局限性,我们发现苯暴露与 NHL、LL、ALL 或总 LN 之间的暴露-反应关系的证据很少,尽管暴露组工人的 NHL 和其他特指 LN 的发病率高于未暴露组工人。