School of Biological and Population Health Sciences, College of Public Health and Human Sciences, Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon.
Public Health Division, Oregon Health Authority, Portland, Oregon.
Am J Ind Med. 2020 Aug;63(8):713-725. doi: 10.1002/ajim.23139. Epub 2020 Jun 1.
The Oregon Occupational Public Health Program (OOPHP) monitors occupational health indicators (OHIs) to inform occupational safety and health (OSH) surveillance. In 2018, OOPHP evaluated the performance of the OSH surveillance system and identified areas for future improvement.
Following the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) updated guidelines for evaluating public health surveillance systems, the OOPHP evaluation team engaged internal and external stakeholders using a mixed-methods approach. Operational measures for ten surveillance attributes were developed. Multiple data collection methods resulted in credible evidence for evaluation conclusions. Analyses included summary statistics and qualitative analysis of interviews, a focus group, and online surveys.
Twenty stakeholders took part in this evaluation, with an average participation rate of 55%. Results showed the Oregon OSH surveillance system was simple, flexible, and highly accepted by its stakeholders. Funding security presents challenges for stability. A lack of timeliness of OHIs, low relevance of OHIs to local OSH issues, and the system's ineffectual data dissemination all limit the usefulness of the OSH surveillance system. A review of key data sources for the system showed good data quality and predictive value positive, but relatively poor sensitivity and representativeness.
The evaluation team successfully adapted attributes and examples in the CDC guidelines to this Oregon OSH surveillance evaluation. The evaluation findings have informed the development of recommendations for improvements to OOPHP's OSH surveillance. Future research is needed to develop guidance specific to OSH surveillance evaluation.
俄勒冈职业公共卫生计划(OOPHP)监测职业健康指标(OHIs),为职业安全与健康(OSH)监测提供信息。2018 年,OOPHP 评估了 OSH 监测系统的性能,并确定了未来改进的方向。
根据疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)更新的公共卫生监测系统评估指南,OOPHP 评估小组采用混合方法,让内部和外部利益相关者参与其中。制定了十个监测属性的操作措施。多种数据收集方法为评估结论提供了可靠的证据。分析包括总结统计数据和对访谈、焦点小组和在线调查的定性分析。
共有 20 名利益相关者参与了此次评估,平均参与率为 55%。结果表明,俄勒冈 OSH 监测系统简单、灵活,深受利益相关者的认可。资金安全是稳定性的挑战。OHIs 的及时性不足、OHIs 与当地 OSH 问题的相关性低、以及系统无效的数据传播都限制了 OSH 监测系统的有用性。对系统关键数据源的审查显示数据质量和阳性预测值良好,但敏感性和代表性相对较差。
评估小组成功地将 CDC 指南中的属性和示例应用于俄勒冈 OSH 监测评估。评估结果为改进 OOPHP 的 OSH 监测提供了建议。未来需要研究制定专门针对 OSH 监测评估的指导方针。