Department of Anthropology, National Museum, Prague, Czech Republic.
Department of Anthropology and Human Genetics, Faculty of Science, Charles University, Prague, Czech Republic.
J Anat. 2020 Oct;237(4):798-809. doi: 10.1111/joa.13246. Epub 2020 Jun 2.
Frontal sinus analysis has potential utility for detecting biologically related individuals. However, the methodological approach to its evaluation, as well as its informative value, have been questioned. The aim of this work is to introduce a new approach to evaluating the frontal sinus using the 'external supraorbital line' (ESOL) and to determine whether there are sex differences within families in frontal sinus measurements and whether frontal sinus similarity reflects known genetic relationships in both measurements and morphology. We examined the skeletal remains of 41 adult individuals (25 males, 16 females), all members of one family over four generations (19th to 20th centuries), including individuals with very close consanguinity. CT images of skulls were acquired, and both the dimensions and morphology of the frontal sinuses were analyzed using their portions above the ESOL. No significant sex differences were found within families based on frontal sinus dimensions. Significant relationships were found between biological distance and the maximum height and morphology of the frontal sinuses. The greatest degree of similarity was found among closely related individuals. Additionally, in several cases, there was a greater degree of similarity between first cousins or grandparents and their grandchildren than among siblings or parents and their children. Total surface, volume and width are not significant indicators of relatedness. Known genetic relationships are also supported by individual morphological features. Variability within families with very close consanguineous relationships was lower than within families with common degrees of consanguinity, although differences are significant only for some variables.
额窦分析在检测具有生物学关系的个体方面具有潜在的应用价值。然而,其评估方法及其信息价值一直受到质疑。本研究旨在引入一种新的方法,通过“眶上外斜线(ESOL)”来评估额窦,并确定额窦测量值是否存在家庭内的性别差异,以及额窦相似性是否反映了测量值和形态学上已知的遗传关系。我们检查了一个四代(19 世纪至 20 世纪)同一家族的 41 名成年个体(25 名男性,16 名女性)的骨骼遗骸,包括具有非常密切血缘关系的个体。获取了颅骨的 CT 图像,并通过 ESOL 上方的额窦部分分析了它们的尺寸和形态。在家庭内部,根据额窦尺寸未发现明显的性别差异。在生物距离与额窦的最大高度和形态之间发现了显著的关系。最密切相关的个体之间具有最大的相似性。此外,在某些情况下,第一代堂兄弟姐妹或祖父母与他们的孙辈之间的相似程度大于兄弟姐妹或父母与他们的子女之间的相似程度。总的表面积、体积和宽度不是相关关系的显著指标。个体形态特征也支持已知的遗传关系。具有非常密切血缘关系的家庭内的变异性低于具有常见血缘关系的家庭内的变异性,尽管只有一些变量的差异具有统计学意义。