Gray Clark, Hopping Douglas, Mueller Valerie
University of North Carolina; Chapel Hill, NC.
Arizona State University; Tempe, AZ.
Clim Change. 2020 May;160(5):103-122. doi: 10.1007/s10584-020-02657-x. Epub 2020 Jan 21.
A persistent concern about the social consequences of climate change is that large, vulnerable populations will be involuntarily displaced. Existing evidence suggests that changes in precipitation and temperature can increase migration in particular contexts, but the potential for this relationship to evolve over time alongside processes of adaptation and development has not been widely explored. To address this issue, we link longitudinal data from 20 thousand Chinese adults from 1989-2011 to external data on climate anomalies, and use this linked dataset to explore how climatic effects on internal migration have changed over time while controlling for potential spatial and temporal confounders. We find that temperature anomalies initially displaced permanent migrants at the beginning of our study period, but that this effect had reversed by the end of the study period. A parallel analysis of income shares suggests that the explanation might lie in climate vulnerability shifting from agricultural to non-agricultural livelihood activities. Taken together with evidence from previous case studies, our results open the door to a potential future in which development and in-situ adaptation allow climate-induced migration to decline over time, even as climate change unfolds.
对气候变化社会后果的一个长期担忧是,大量易受影响的人口将被迫流离失所。现有证据表明,降水和温度的变化在特定情况下会增加迁移,但随着适应和发展进程,这种关系随时间演变的可能性尚未得到广泛探讨。为解决这一问题,我们将1989年至2011年来自2万名中国成年人的纵向数据与气候异常的外部数据相链接,并使用这个链接数据集来探讨在控制潜在的空间和时间混杂因素的同时,气候对国内迁移的影响是如何随时间变化的。我们发现,在研究期开始时,温度异常最初使永久移民流离失所,但到研究期结束时,这种影响发生了逆转。对收入份额的平行分析表明,解释可能在于气候脆弱性从农业生计活动转向非农业生计活动。结合先前案例研究的证据,我们的结果为未来的一种可能性打开了大门,即即使气候变化持续,发展和就地适应也可能使气候引发的迁移随时间减少。