Gray Clark, Wise Erika
Department of Geography, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC 27599.
Clim Change. 2016 Apr;135(3):555-568. doi: 10.1007/s10584-015-1592-y. Epub 2016 Jan 9.
Involuntary human migration is among the social outcomes of greatest concern in the current era of global climate change. Responding to this concern, a growing number of studies have investigated the consequences of short to medium-term climate variability for human migration using demographic and econometric approaches. These studies have provided important insights, but at the same time have been significantly limited by lack of expertise in the use of climate data, access to cross-national data on migration, and attention to model specification. To address these limitations, we link data on internal and international migration over a 6-year period from 9,812 origin households in Kenya, Uganda, Nigeria, Burkina Faso and Senegal to high-resolution gridded climate data from both station and satellite sources. Analyses of these data using several plausible specifications reveal that climate variability has country-specific effects on migration: Migration tends to increase with temperature anomalies in Uganda, tends to decrease with temperature anomalies in Kenya and Burkina Faso, and shows no consistent relationship with temperature in Nigeria and Senegal. Consistent with previous studies, precipitation shows weak and inconsistent relationships with migration across countries. These results challenge generalizing narratives that foresee a consistent migratory response to climate change across the globe.
在当前全球气候变化时代,非自愿性人口迁移是最受关注的社会后果之一。针对这一关切,越来越多的研究使用人口统计学和计量经济学方法,调查了短期至中期气候变率对人口迁移的影响。这些研究提供了重要的见解,但与此同时,由于缺乏气候数据使用方面的专业知识、获取跨国移民数据的渠道以及对模型设定的关注,这些研究受到了很大限制。为解决这些限制,我们将肯尼亚、乌干达、尼日利亚、布基纳法索和塞内加尔9812个原籍家庭在6年期间的国内和国际移民数据,与来自地面站和卫星源的高分辨率网格化气候数据相链接。使用几种合理设定对这些数据进行分析后发现,气候变率对移民有国别效应:在乌干达,移民往往随着温度异常而增加;在肯尼亚和布基纳法索,移民往往随着温度异常而减少;在尼日利亚和塞内加尔,移民与温度没有一致的关系。与先前的研究一致,降水在各国与移民之间呈现出微弱且不一致的关系。这些结果挑战了那种预见全球对气候变化会有一致移民反应的普遍说法。