Center for Bioethics and Social Sciences in Medicine, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Department of Public Health, Teikyo University School of Medicine, Kaga 2-11-1, Itabashi-ku, Tokyo, 173-8605, Japan.
BMC Med Educ. 2020 Jun 3;20(1):178. doi: 10.1186/s12909-020-02072-x.
Physician-scientists are a vital segment of the healthcare workforce, but they may face significant challenges balancing and integrating clinical responsibilities, scientific research, and domestic responsibilities. This study investigates factors associated with burnout among highly successful early career physician-researchers in Japan.
Among 1790 physician awardees of Grant-in-Aid for Young Scientists by the Japanese Ministry in 2014-2015, 490 participated in this cross-sectional survey in 2016 (usable response rate 23.8%). The primary outcome was psychological burnout, measured by the Copenhagen Burnout Inventory (i.e., personal burnout, work-related burnout, and patient-related burnout). "Workplace resources" in our study refers to the presence of career education in the workplace, promotion of gender equity, well-being consultation services on "career and work," "research," "harassment," and/or "mental health," as well as the presence of a role model in the workplace who has perceived good work-life balance.
Among 408 physician-researchers (75% male, mean age 37 yrs), personal burnout scores were slightly higher in women than in men (mean score, 41.9 points vs. 36.7 points, difference, 5.2, 95% confidence interval, 0.5-9.9, p = 0.029), but work-related and patient-related burnout scores did not differ significantly between genders. Over half of women (64%) and men (58%) had a mentor (p = 0.374). In multivariable general linear regression models, personal burnout scores were higher for women (β = 4.98, p = 0.045), and lower among those who had a mentor (β = - 5.82, p = 0.010) and whose workplaces had well-being consultation services (β = - 0.79, p = 0.022). Work-related burnout scores were lower among those with larger amounts of grant funding (β = - 4.70, p = 0.013), a mentor (β = - 6.12, p = 0.002), well-being consultation services (β = - 0.78, p = 0.008) and a role model with a perceived good work-life balance (β = - 4.00, p = 0.038). Patient-related burnout scores were higher among physician-scientists aged older than 37 years (β = 6.25, p = 0.002) and those who had board certification (β = 9.01, p = 0.017), while these scores were lower among those had larger amounts of funding (β = - 5.01, p = 0.006) or a mentor (β = - 5.35, p = 0.006).
Workplace resources and mentorship appear to be associated with lower levels of psychological burnout for both men and women early career physician-scientists.
医师科学家是医疗保健劳动力中至关重要的一部分,但他们在平衡和整合临床职责、科学研究和家庭责任方面可能面临重大挑战。本研究调查了与日本高成就的早期职业医师研究员职业倦怠相关的因素。
在日本 2014-2015 年获得青年科学家补助计划补助的 1790 名医师奖获得者中,2016 年有 490 人参加了这项横断面调查(可使用的回复率为 23.8%)。主要结局是心理倦怠,通过哥本哈根倦怠量表(即个人倦怠、与工作相关的倦怠和与患者相关的倦怠)来衡量。我们研究中的“工作场所资源”是指工作场所是否存在职业教育、促进性别平等、是否提供有关“职业和工作”、“研究”、“骚扰”和/或“心理健康”的福利咨询服务,以及工作场所是否存在工作生活平衡感知良好的榜样。
在 408 名医师研究员中(75%为男性,平均年龄 37 岁),女性的个人倦怠得分略高于男性(平均得分分别为 41.9 分和 36.7 分,差异为 5.2,95%置信区间为 0.5-9.9,p=0.029),但两性之间的与工作相关的倦怠和与患者相关的倦怠得分没有显著差异。超过一半的女性(64%)和男性(58%)有导师(p=0.374)。在多变量一般线性回归模型中,女性的个人倦怠得分更高(β=4.98,p=0.045),而有导师(β=-5.82,p=0.010)和工作场所提供福利咨询服务(β=-0.79,p=0.022)的女性得分较低。与工作相关的倦怠得分较低的是那些获得更多资助(β=-4.70,p=0.013)、有导师(β=-6.12,p=0.002)、福利咨询服务(β=-0.78,p=0.008)和工作生活平衡感知良好的榜样(β=-4.00,p=0.038)的医师科学家。年龄大于 37 岁的医师科学家(β=6.25,p=0.002)和具有董事会认证的医师科学家(β=9.01,p=0.017)的患者相关倦怠得分较高,而那些获得更多资助(β=-5.01,p=0.006)或有导师(β=-5.35,p=0.006)的医师科学家的患者相关倦怠得分较低。
工作场所资源和指导似乎与男性和女性早期职业医师科学家的心理倦怠程度较低有关。