Vanderbilt University Institute of Imaging Science, Nashville, TN 37232, United States.
Department of Radiology and Radiological Sciences, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN 37232, United States.
J Immunother Cancer. 2020 Jun;8(1). doi: 10.1136/jitc-2019-000328.
Immune checkpoint inhibitors, the most widespread class of immunotherapies, have demonstrated unique response patterns that are not always adequately captured by traditional response criteria such as the Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors or even immune-specific response criteria. These response metrics rely on monitoring tumor growth, but an increase in tumor size and/or appearance after starting immunotherapy does not always represent tumor progression, but also can be a result of T cell infiltration and thus positive treatment response. Therefore, non-invasive and longitudinal monitoring of T cell infiltration are needed to assess the effects of immunotherapies such as checkpoint inhibitors. Here, we proposed an innovative concept that a sufficiently large influx of tumor infiltrating T cells, which have a smaller diameter than cancer cells, will change the diameter distribution and decrease the average size of cells within a volume to a degree that can be quantified by non-invasive MRI.
We validated our hypothesis by studying tumor response to combination immune-checkpoint blockade (ICB) of anti-PD-1 and anti-CTLA4 in a mouse model of colon adenocarcinoma (MC38). The response was monitored longitudinally using Imaging Microstructural Parameters Using Limited Spectrally Edited Diffusion (IMPULSED), a diffusion MRI-based method which has been previously shown to non-invasively map changes in intracellular structure and cell sizes with the spatial resolution of MRI, in cell cultures and in animal models. Tumors were collected for immunohistochemical and flow cytometry analyzes immediately after the last imaging session.
Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that increased T cell infiltration of the tumors results in a decrease in mean cell size (eg, a 10% increase of CD3 T cell fraction results a ~1 µm decrease in the mean cell size). IMPULSED showed that the ICB responders, mice with tumor volumes were less than 250 mm or had tumors with stable or decreased volumes, had significantly smaller mean cell sizes than both Control IgG-treated tumors and ICB non-responder tumors.
IMPULSED-derived cell size could potentially serve as an imaging marker for differentiating responsive and non-responsive tumors after checkpoint inhibitor therapies, a current clinical challenge that is not solved by simply monitoring tumor growth.
免疫检查点抑制剂是最广泛的一类免疫疗法,其显示出独特的反应模式,这些模式并不总是能被传统的反应标准(如实体瘤反应评估标准,甚至是免疫特异性反应标准)充分捕捉到。这些反应指标依赖于监测肿瘤生长,但在开始免疫治疗后肿瘤大小和/或外观的增加并不总是代表肿瘤进展,也可能是 T 细胞浸润的结果,因此是积极的治疗反应。因此,需要非侵入性和纵向监测 T 细胞浸润,以评估免疫检查点抑制剂等免疫疗法的效果。在这里,我们提出了一个创新的概念,即足够大量的肿瘤浸润 T 细胞的涌入,其直径小于癌细胞,将改变直径分布,并在一定程度上降低体积内细胞的平均大小,这种程度可以通过非侵入性 MRI 来量化。
我们通过研究抗 PD-1 和抗 CTLA4 联合免疫检查点阻断(ICB)在结肠腺癌(MC38)小鼠模型中的肿瘤反应,验证了我们的假设。反应通过使用基于扩散 MRI 的方法——成像微观结构参数使用有限光谱编辑扩散(IMPULSED)进行纵向监测,该方法以前已经显示出可以非侵入性地映射细胞内结构和细胞大小的变化,具有 MRI 的空间分辨率,在细胞培养物和动物模型中。在最后一次成像后,立即收集肿瘤进行免疫组织化学和流式细胞术分析。
免疫组织化学分析显示,肿瘤中 T 细胞浸润的增加导致平均细胞大小减小(例如,CD3 T 细胞分数增加 10%,平均细胞大小减小约 1μm)。IMPULSED 显示,ICB 反应者,即肿瘤体积小于 250mm 或肿瘤体积稳定或减小的小鼠,其平均细胞大小明显小于对照 IgG 治疗的肿瘤和 ICB 无反应者的肿瘤。
IMPULSED 衍生的细胞大小可能潜在地作为区分检查点抑制剂治疗后反应性和非反应性肿瘤的成像标志物,这是当前临床挑战,通过简单地监测肿瘤生长并不能解决。