Dougas G, Mellou K, Kostoulas P, Billinis C, Georgakopoulou T, Tsiodras S
Zoonoses Unit, Hellenic National Public Health Organization, Athens, Greece.
Department of Veterinary Epidemiology, Faculty of Veterinary Science, University of Thessaly, Karditsa, Greece.
Hippokratia. 2019 Jul-Sep;23(3):106-110.
spp. isolation is one of the mainstays of brucellosis diagnosis. Simultaneously, the true brucellosis disease rate may be underrepresented in notification systems. This study aims at assessing the nosocomial capacity for spp. isolation and the underreporting rate of brucellosis cases in Greece.
Data for spp. culture capacity and the number of isolations were collected annually from public hospitals nationwide, during 2015-2018. The number of unreported cases was estimated after subtracting the National Mandatory Notification System cases from the survey-captured isolations, matched by hospital and year.
Feedback was provided by 112 public hospitals (response rate: 97.4 %). spp. isolation capacity was completely absent in 27.7 % of hospitals; during the four years of the study, 11.3 %, 13.9 %, 20.0 %, and 25.2 % of the hospitals had isolation competence for one, two, three, or four years, respectively. Underreporting assessment was possible in hospitals that declared at least one spp. isolation (n =35) and unreported cases were identified in 19 (54 %). Α mean underreporting of 28.9 % of total cases was estimated for the whole period of the study ranging annually from 24.1 % to 35.0 %. The number of unreported cases per hospital ranged from one to 12 per year (median: 2, IQR: 5).
Interventions for improving diagnosis and reporting of the disease are recommended. Assessment of brucellosis underreporting by comparing raw numerical data of survey-captured isolations and officially notified cases lacks the case by case specificity, however, keeping required data to a minimum achieves high feedback rate from hospitals and provides a tentative estimation of the notification deficit. HIPPOKRATIA 2019, 23(3): 106-110.
布鲁氏菌属分离培养是布鲁氏菌病诊断的主要手段之一。同时,在报告系统中,布鲁氏菌病的实际发病率可能未得到充分体现。本研究旨在评估希腊医院对布鲁氏菌属的分离培养能力以及布鲁氏菌病病例的漏报率。
2015年至2018年期间,每年收集全国公立医院布鲁氏菌属培养能力和分离培养数量的数据。通过将调查获取的分离培养病例数(按医院和年份匹配)减去国家强制报告系统中的病例数,估算未报告病例数。
112家公立医院提供了反馈(回复率:97.4%)。27.7%的医院完全没有布鲁氏菌属分离培养能力;在研究的四年中,分别有11.3%、13.9%、20.0%和25.2%的医院具备一、二、三或四年的分离培养能力。在报告至少有一次布鲁氏菌属分离培养的医院(n = 35)中可以进行漏报评估,其中19家(54%)发现了未报告病例。整个研究期间估计平均漏报率为总病例数的28.9%,每年范围为24.1%至35.0%。每家医院每年未报告病例数从1例到12例不等(中位数:2,四分位间距:5)。
建议采取干预措施以改善该疾病的诊断和报告。通过比较调查获取的分离培养病例原始数据和官方报告病例来评估布鲁氏菌病漏报情况,缺乏逐案特异性,然而,将所需数据保持在最低限度可实现医院的高反馈率,并提供漏报情况的初步估计。《希波克拉底》2019年,23(3): 106 - 110。