Scheepers F E, de Mul J, Boer F, Hoogendijk W J
Tijdschr Psychiatr. 2020;62(6):472-480.
From an evolutionary perspective it is remarkable that psychotic disorders, mostly occurring during fertile age and decreasing fecundity, maintain in the human population.
AIM: To argue the hypothesis that psychotic symptoms may not be viewed as an illness but as an adaptation phenomenon.
METHOD: Philosophical consideration and literature study.
RESULTS: Until now, biomedical research has not unraveled the definitive etiology of psychotic disorders. Findings are inconsistent and show non-specific brain anomalies and genetic variation with small effect sizes. However, compelling evidence was found for a relation between psychosis and stressful environmental factors, particularly those influencing social interaction. Psychotic symptoms may be explained as a natural defense mechanism or protective response to stressful environments. This is in line with the fact that psychotic symptoms most often develop during adolescence. In this phase of life, it is important for an individual's development to leave the familiar and safe home environment, and to build new social networks. This could cause symptoms of 'hyperconsciousness' and calls on the capacity for social adaptation. This mechanism can become out of control due to different underlying brain vulnerabilities and external stressors, leading to social exclusion. CONCLUSIONS There is theoretical ground to consider psychotic symptoms as an evolutionary maintained phenomenon. Research investigating psychotic disorders may benefit from a focus on underlying general brain vulnerabilities or prevention of social exclusion, instead of regarding psychotic symptoms as abnormal phenomena.
从进化的角度来看,精神疾病大多发生在育龄期且会降低生育能力,却仍在人类群体中存在,这一点很值得注意。
论证精神症状可能不应被视为一种疾病,而应被视为一种适应现象的假说。
哲学思考与文献研究。
到目前为止,生物医学研究尚未揭示精神疾病的确切病因。研究结果并不一致,显示出非特异性的脑部异常和效应量较小的基因变异。然而,有确凿证据表明精神病与压力性环境因素之间存在关联,尤其是那些影响社会互动的因素。精神症状可被解释为对压力环境的一种自然防御机制或保护性反应。这与精神症状最常出现在青春期这一事实相符。在人生的这个阶段,个体离开熟悉且安全的家庭环境、建立新的社交网络对其发展很重要。这可能会引发“过度意识”症状,并需要社会适应能力。由于不同的潜在脑部易损性和外部压力源,这种机制可能会失控,导致社会排斥。
有理论依据将精神症状视为一种进化上维持的现象。研究精神疾病可能会受益于关注潜在的一般脑部易损性或预防社会排斥,而不是将精神症状视为异常现象。