Department of Community Health Sciences, Rady Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB, Canada.
Int J Health Policy Manag. 2021 Mar 14;10(4):218-220. doi: 10.34172/ijhpm.2020.60.
According to Iverson and colleagues' thoughtful analysis, decisions to decentralize or regionalize surgical services must take into account contextual realities that may impede the safe execution of certain delivery models in low-and middle-income countries (LMICs), and should be governed by procedure-related considerations (specifically, volume, patient acuity, and procedure complexity). This commentary suggests that, by shifting attention to the mechanisms whereby (de)centralization may exert beneficial impacts, it is possible to generate guidance applicable to countries across the socioeconomic spectrum. Four key mechanisms can be identified: decentralization (1) minimizes the need for patients to travel for care and, (2) obviates certain system-induced delays once patients present; centralization (3) facilitates the maintenance of a workforce with sufficient expertise to offer services safely, and (4) conserves resources by limiting the number of sites. The commentary elucidates how context- and procedure-related factors determine the importance of each mechanism, allowing planners to prioritize among them. Although some context factors have special relevance to LMICs, most can also appear in high-income countries (HICs), and the procedure-related factors are universal. Thus, evidence from countries at all income levels might be fruitfully combined into an integrated body of context-sensitive guidance.
根据艾弗森和同事们的深入分析,决策是否将手术服务去中心化或区域化,必须考虑到可能阻碍某些交付模式在中低收入国家(LMICs)安全实施的背景现实,并且应该受到与程序相关的考虑因素(具体来说,是手术量、患者病情严重程度和手术复杂度)的制约。本评论认为,通过关注去中心化可能产生有益影响的机制,就有可能为社会经济状况各异的国家提供适用的指导。可以确定四个关键机制:去中心化(1)使患者减少求医出行的需求,(2)避免患者就诊时出现某些系统诱导的延误;中心化(3)有助于维持具有足够专业知识以安全提供服务的劳动力队伍,(4)通过限制站点数量来节约资源。本评论阐明了与背景和程序相关的因素如何决定每个机制的重要性,使规划者能够对它们进行优先排序。虽然一些背景因素对 LMICs 具有特殊意义,但大多数因素也可能出现在高收入国家(HICs)中,而与程序相关的因素则是普遍存在的。因此,来自所有收入水平国家的证据可以被有效地结合到一个具有背景敏感性的综合指导体系中。