Cabral M, Taylor R, de Vos C J
Animal and Plant Health Agency United Kingdom.
EFSA J. 2019 Sep 17;17(Suppl 2):e170916. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2019.e170916. eCollection 2019 Sep.
This Technical Report describes the activities developed in the scope of the EU-FORA Fellowship, within the work programme of risk assessment (RA) of exotic disease incursion and spread, developed at Wageningen Bioveterinary Research (WBVR). The programme focused on the work carried out in the Generic risk assessment for introduction of animal diseases (G-RAID) project, which brings together a number of different generic RA tools from multiple European partners. The aim of the fellowship was to gain understanding of veterinary import risk assessment by using different RA tools and to learn how different algorithms can be used to calculate disease incursion risks. G-RAID's tools cover a wide range of RA methodologies; from purely qualitative, to semi-quantitative and fully stochastic quantitative methods, which allowed the fellow to understand a variety of algorithms used to produce the final risk estimate. The fellowship programme provided the fellow with the chance to learn in detail about how generic RAs are performed across Europe, understanding how to deal with the uncertainty and variability involved in RAs and the potential problems of data availability and reliability. The fellow made an inventory of publicly available databases on disease occurrence and international trade that could be used for import RA and assessed their quality and usefulness for the different generic RA tools. The programme also provided the fellow the opportunity to perform several import risk assessments using the RA tools of G-RAID. She completed a RA on African swine fever using the MINTRISK model developed by WBVR. Furthermore, she assessed the risk of foot and mouth disease introduction using the Rapid Risk Assessment Tool (RRAT) model developed by WBVR and the COMPARE model developed by the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA). To this end, the fellow completed a short-term visit to APHA, enabling her to have additional training in quantitative RA and to expand her professional network in this area.
本技术报告描述了在欧盟-福拉奖学金范围内开展的活动,这些活动属于瓦赫宁根生物兽医研究中心(WBVR)制定的外来疾病入侵和传播风险评估(RA)工作计划。该计划重点关注动物疾病引入通用风险评估(G-RAID)项目中开展的工作,该项目汇集了多个欧洲伙伴的多种不同通用RA工具。该奖学金的目的是通过使用不同的RA工具来了解兽医进口风险评估,并学习如何使用不同的算法来计算疾病入侵风险。G-RAID的工具涵盖了广泛的RA方法;从纯定性方法到半定量方法和完全随机定量方法,这使该研究员能够理解用于得出最终风险估计的各种算法。该奖学金计划为该研究员提供了详细了解欧洲各地如何进行通用RA的机会,了解如何处理RA中涉及的不确定性和变异性以及数据可用性和可靠性方面的潜在问题。该研究员编制了一份关于疾病发生情况和国际贸易的公开可用数据库清单,这些数据库可用于进口RA,并评估了它们对不同通用RA工具的质量和有用性。该计划还为该研究员提供了使用G-RAID的RA工具进行几次进口风险评估的机会。她使用WBVR开发的MINTRISK模型完成了非洲猪瘟的风险评估。此外,她使用WBVR开发的快速风险评估工具(RRAT)模型和动植物卫生机构(APHA)开发的COMPARE模型评估了口蹄疫引入的风险。为此,该研究员对APHA进行了短期访问,使她能够接受定量RA方面的额外培训,并扩大她在该领域的专业网络。