Cooper Vaughn S, Warren Taylor M, Matela Abigail M, Handwork Michael, Scarponi Shani
Department of Microbiology and Molecular Genetics, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA USA.
Center for Evolutionary Biology and Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA USA.
Evolution (N Y). 2019;12(1):12. doi: 10.1186/s12052-019-0103-4. Epub 2019 Apr 24.
Evolution is a central, unifying theory for all of life science, yet the subject is poorly represented in most secondary-school biology courses, especially in the United States. One challenge to learning evolution is that it is taught as a conceptual, retrospective subject with few tangible outcomes for students. These typical passive learning strategies lead to student disengagement with the material and misunderstanding of evolutionary concepts. To promote greater investment and comprehension, we developed EvolvingSTEM, an inquiry-based laboratory curriculum that demonstrates concepts of natural selection, heredity, and ecological diversity through experimental evolution of a benign bacterium. Students transfer populations of growing on plastic beads, which selects for biofilm formation and mutants with new, conspicuous phenotypes. We introduced our curriculum to four introductory high school biology classes alongside their standard curriculum materials and found that students who learned evolution through EvolvingSTEM scored significantly better on a common assessment targeted to Next Generation Science Standards than students taught only the standard curriculum. This latter group subsequently achieved similar scores once they too completed our curriculum. Our work demonstrates that inquiry-based, hands-on experiences with evolving bacterial populations can greatly enhance student learning of evolutionary concepts.
进化是所有生命科学的核心统一理论,但在大多数中学的生物课程中,这一主题的呈现却很不足,尤其是在美国。学习进化面临的一个挑战是,它被当作一门概念性的、回顾性的学科来教授,对学生来说几乎没有切实可见的成果。这些典型的被动学习策略导致学生对学习内容缺乏参与度,对进化概念产生误解。为了促使学生更多地投入学习并加深理解,我们开发了EvolvingSTEM,这是一门基于探究的实验课程,通过一种良性细菌的实验进化来展示自然选择、遗传和生态多样性的概念。学生转移在塑料珠上生长的菌群,这会选择形成生物膜的菌群以及具有新的、明显表型的突变体。我们将我们的课程与标准课程材料一起引入了四门高中生物入门课程,并发现通过EvolvingSTEM学习进化的学生在针对《下一代科学标准》的共同评估中的得分,显著高于只学习标准课程的学生。后一组学生在完成我们的课程后也取得了类似的分数。我们的工作表明,对不断进化的细菌群体进行基于探究的实践体验,能够极大地提高学生对进化概念的学习效果。