Collins S, Iansek R
Neurology Department, Monash Medical Centre, Prince Henry's Hospital, Melbourne, Vic.
Clin Exp Neurol. 1988;25:103-8.
Patients referred to a neurology clinic with their first episode of loss of consciousness were studied prospectively in order to clarify the positive predictive value of an epileptic EEG for establishing an epileptic cause of the loss of consciousness. The clinical diagnosis was categorised as epileptic or non-epileptic. The EEG was reported as epileptic or non-epileptic, but abnormal or normal, according to recognised criteria. Patients were followed for a period ranging from 1 to 18 months to assess the accuracy of the original diagnosis. A total of 38 patients were available for analysis. Thirteen patients had a clinical diagnosis of epilepsy and 25 patients had a non-epileptic diagnosis. Five patients with an epileptic history had an epileptic EEG and 2 patients with a non-epileptic history had an epileptic EEG. Non-epileptic EEG abnormalities were present in a further 4 patients with a non-epileptic history. Follow-up was achieved for 53% of patients and in none of these was the final diagnosis different from the initial one. The positive predictive value of an epileptic EEG for a diagnosis of epilepsy was 71%, and the negative predictive value of a normal EEG for a diagnosis of non-epilepsy was 74%. The positive predictive value for any abnormality in the EEG for a diagnosis of epilepsy was 45%, and the negative predictive value of an absence of any abnormality in the EEG for a diagnosis of non-epilepsy was 70%.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
为了明确癫痫性脑电图对于确立意识丧失的癫痫病因的阳性预测价值,对首次因意识丧失就诊于神经科门诊的患者进行了前瞻性研究。临床诊断分为癫痫性或非癫痫性。脑电图根据公认标准报告为癫痫性或非癫痫性,以及异常或正常。对患者进行了1至18个月的随访,以评估初始诊断的准确性。共有38例患者可供分析。13例患者临床诊断为癫痫,25例患者诊断为非癫痫。5例有癫痫病史的患者脑电图为癫痫性,2例无癫痫病史的患者脑电图为癫痫性。另有4例无癫痫病史的患者脑电图存在非癫痫性异常。53%的患者获得了随访,且这些患者中最终诊断与初始诊断均无差异。癫痫性脑电图对癫痫诊断的阳性预测值为71%,正常脑电图对非癫痫诊断的阴性预测值为74%。脑电图任何异常对癫痫诊断的阳性预测值为45%,脑电图无任何异常对非癫痫诊断的阴性预测值为70%。(摘要截取自250字)