Havy Mélanie, Nazzi Thierry
Université Paris Descartes, France.
CNRS and Université Paris Descartes, France.
Infancy. 2009 Jul 8;14(4):439-456. doi: 10.1080/15250000902996532. Epub 2009 Jul 1.
Previous research using the name-based categorization task has shown that 20-month-old infants can simultaneously learn 2 words that only differ by 1 consonantal feature but fail to do so when the words only differ by 1 vocalic feature. This asymmetry was taken as evidence for the proposal that consonants are more important than vowels at the lexical level. This study explores this consonant-vowel asymmetry in 16-month-old infants, using an interactive word learning task. It shows that the pattern of the 16-month-olds is the same as that of the 20-month-olds. Infants succeeded with 1-feature consonantal contrasts (either place or voicing) but were at chance level with 1-feature vocalic contrasts (either place or height). These results thus contribute to a growing body of evidence establishing, from early infancy to adulthood, that consonants and vowels have different roles in lexical acquisition and processing.
以往使用基于名称分类任务的研究表明,20个月大的婴儿能够同时学习仅相差1个辅音特征的两个单词,但当单词仅相差1个元音特征时则无法做到。这种不对称被视为一种证据,支持了在词汇层面辅音比元音更重要这一观点。本研究使用交互式单词学习任务,探究了16个月大婴儿的这种辅音-元音不对称现象。结果表明,16个月大婴儿的模式与20个月大婴儿的相同。婴儿在1个特征的辅音对比(部位或清浊)上取得了成功,但在1个特征的元音对比(部位或高低)上则处于随机水平。因此,这些结果为越来越多的证据做出了贡献,这些证据表明,从婴儿早期到成年期,辅音和元音在词汇习得和处理中具有不同的作用。