Nazzi Thierry, Bertoncini Josiane
Laboratoire Psychologie de la Perception, Université Paris Descartes, CNRS, Paris, France.
Lang Speech. 2009;52(Pt 4):463-80. doi: 10.1177/0023830909336584.
Use of precise consonantal information while learning new words has been established for onset consonants in previous studies, which showed that infants as young as 16 to 20 months of age can simultaneously learn two new words that differ only by a syllable-initial consonant (Havy & Nazzi, 2009; Nazzi, 2005; Nazzi & New, 2007; Werker, Fennell, Corcoran, & Stager, 2002). However, there is no systematic evidence to show whether specific phonetic information in other positions within the syllable can be used while learning new words. To the contrary, Nazzi (2005) found that when tested using the same task, 20-month-olds can learn two words that differ only by a consonant, but fail to do so if they differ only by a vowel, leaving open the possibility that specificity is limited to syllable-onset positions. Accordingly, the present study evaluated 20-month-olds' ability to learn two words that differ only by a consonant in either onset or coda position. Infants succeeded for both positions, ruling out the possibility that only syllable-onset positions are specified. This further suggests that the previously reported consonant/ vowel asymmetry cannot be fully explained by syllable-onset positional effects. Additionally, the present study evaluated whether words following a predominant labial-coronal pattern would be easier to learn than less frequent coronal-labial words. It failed to obtain any such evidence.
在先前的研究中,针对起始辅音,已经证实了在学习新单词时使用精确的辅音信息,这些研究表明,年仅16至20个月的婴儿能够同时学习两个仅在音节起始辅音上不同的新单词(哈维 & 纳齐,2009;纳齐,2005;纳齐 & 纽,2007;韦克、芬内尔、科科伦 & 斯塔格,2002)。然而,没有系统的证据表明在学习新单词时是否可以使用音节内其他位置的特定语音信息。相反,纳齐(2005)发现,当使用相同任务进行测试时,20个月大的婴儿能够学习两个仅在辅音上不同的单词,但如果它们仅在元音上不同则无法做到,这使得特异性仅限于音节起始位置的可能性仍然存在。因此,本研究评估了20个月大的婴儿学习两个仅在起始或结尾位置的辅音上不同的单词的能力。婴儿在两个位置上都成功了,排除了仅音节起始位置被明确指定的可能性。这进一步表明,先前报道的辅音/元音不对称不能完全由音节起始位置效应来解释。此外,本研究评估了遵循主要唇-冠模式的单词是否比不太常见的冠-唇单词更容易学习。但未获得任何此类证据。