Faculty of Medicine and Health Technology, Tampere University, Tampere, Finland.
Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2020 Jul 23;15(7):e0236258. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0236258. eCollection 2020.
Parkinson's disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative disease inducing dystrophy of the motor system. Automatic movement analysis systems have potential in improving patient care by enabling personalized and more accurate adjust of treatment. These systems utilize machine learning to classify the movement properties based on the features derived from the signals. Smartphones can provide an inexpensive measurement platform with their built-in sensors for movement assessment. This study compared three feature selection and nine classification methods for identifying PD patients from control subjects based on accelerometer and gyroscope signals measured with a smartphone during a 20-step walking test. Minimum Redundancy Maximum Relevance (mRMR) and sequential feature selection with both forward (SFS) and backward (SBS) propagation directions were used in this study. The number of selected features was narrowed down from 201 to 4-15 features by applying SFS and mRMR methods. From the methods compared in this study, the highest accuracy for individual steps was achieved with SFS (7 features) and Naive Bayes classifier (accuracy 75.3%), and the second highest accuracy with SFS (4 features) and k Nearest neighbours (accuracy 75.1%). Leave-one-subject-out cross-validation was used in the analysis. For the overall classification of each subject, which was based on the majority vote of the classified steps, k Nearest Neighbors provided the most accurate result with an accuracy of 84.5% and an error rate of 15.5%. This study shows the differences in feature selection methods and classifiers and provides generalizations for optimizing methodologies for smartphone-based monitoring of PD patients. The results are promising for further developing the analysis system for longer measurements carried out in free-living conditions.
帕金森病(PD)是一种神经退行性疾病,会导致运动系统的萎缩。自动运动分析系统通过实现个性化和更准确的治疗调整,具有改善患者护理的潜力。这些系统利用机器学习根据从信号中提取的特征对运动特性进行分类。智能手机可以利用其内置传感器提供廉价的测量平台,用于运动评估。本研究比较了基于智能手机在 20 步行走测试期间测量的加速度计和陀螺仪信号,基于特征选择和 9 种分类方法,从对照组中识别 PD 患者。本研究使用最小冗余最大相关性(mRMR)和前向(SFS)和后向(SBS)传播方向的顺序特征选择方法。通过应用 SFS 和 mRMR 方法,将所选特征的数量从 201 个减少到 4-15 个。在本研究中比较的方法中,个体步骤的最高准确性是使用 SFS(7 个特征)和朴素贝叶斯分类器(准确性为 75.3%)实现的,其次是 SFS(4 个特征)和 k 最近邻(准确性为 75.1%)。分析中使用了一次留一受试者交叉验证。对于基于分类步骤多数票的每个受试者的整体分类,k 最近邻提供了最准确的结果,准确率为 84.5%,错误率为 15.5%。本研究表明了特征选择方法和分类器的差异,并为优化基于智能手机的 PD 患者监测的方法学提供了概括。这些结果为进一步开发在自由生活条件下进行更长时间测量的分析系统提供了希望。