Klawitter Marcus, Braden Theo Broderick, Müller Kerstin Elisabeth
Clinic for Ruminants and Swine, Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
MSSW, School of Medicine, UW-Madison, Madison, WI 53706, United States.
Vet Anim Sci. 2019 Aug 28;8:100070. doi: 10.1016/j.vas.2019.100070. eCollection 2019 Dec.
This randomized clinical trial investigated the effect of bandaging on 56 uncomplicated sole ulcers (SU) among a sample of 52 dairy cows. Following therapeutic hoof trimming and povidone-iodine treatment, all cows received a wooden block on the unaffected claw and were randomly assigned into either a bandaged or non-bandaged group. The bandaging process was standardized and applied by the same veterinarian. Wound size and locomotion were measured weekly. Overall, 19 of 32 SU (59.4%) in the non-bandaged group were healed at week 4 compared to 7 of 24 ulcers (29.2%) in the bandaged group. Healing was significantly higher for non-bandaged than bandaged SU ( = 0.024). Bandaging had no effect on locomotion ( = 0.9). Cows with a lower locomotion (Sprecher 1 + 2) had significantly smaller lesion sizes (median lesion size, 0.5 cm², IQR = 0.21 to 0.92 cm²) than animals with locomotion score 3-5 (median lesion size, 0.9 cm², IQR = 0.42 to 1.81 cm²; < 0.001). A multivariate cox proportional hazard regression indicated that bandaging and parity had a significant effect on healing. Specifically, bandaged SU had a significantly lower hazard ratio (HR) to cure compared to non-bandaged SU (HR = 0.32; = 0.01; 95% CI = 0.13 to 0.78). Furthermore, cows with parity ≥3 had a significantly higher HR to cure compared to cows in their first lactation (HR = 2.73; = 0.025; 95% CI = 1.14 to 6.56).
这项随机临床试验研究了包扎对52头奶牛样本中56处单纯性蹄底溃疡(SU)的影响。在进行治疗性蹄修剪和聚维酮碘治疗后,所有奶牛在未受影响的蹄爪上放置一个木块,并被随机分为包扎组或非包扎组。包扎过程由同一位兽医进行标准化操作。每周测量伤口大小和运动能力。总体而言,非包扎组32处SU中有19处(59.4%)在第4周愈合,而包扎组24处溃疡中有7处(29.2%)愈合。非包扎的SU愈合率显著高于包扎的SU(P = 0.024)。包扎对运动能力没有影响(P = 0.9)。运动能力较低(Sprecher 1 + 2)的奶牛病变大小(中位数病变大小,0.5 cm²,IQR = 0.21至0.92 cm²)明显小于运动评分3 - 5的动物(中位数病变大小,0.9 cm²,IQR = 0.42至1.81 cm²;P < 0.001)。多变量考克斯比例风险回归表明,包扎和胎次对愈合有显著影响。具体而言,与非包扎的SU相比,包扎的SU治愈的风险比(HR)显著更低(HR = 0.32;P = 0.01;95% CI = 0.13至0.78)。此外,与头胎奶牛相比,胎次≥3的奶牛治愈的HR显著更高(HR = 2.73;P = 0.025;95% CI = 1.14至6.56)。