Institute of Archaeology, University College London, London, UK.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2020 Oct;173(2):381-392. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.24109. Epub 2020 Aug 4.
The recent proliferation of methods of 3D model generation has enabled the development of new approaches to the analysis of dental form, function and wear. This article assesses whether Structure-from-motion (SfM) photogrammetry is capable of producing virtual 3D models of teeth of adequate quality for assessing fine scale surface details, such as dental macrowear patterns. Reference models were generated using a high resolution structured light scanner to assess the accuracy of the photogrammetric models generated.
Dental gypsum models of the molar teeth of human individuals from St. Michael's Litten, Chichester, Post-medieval assemblage (n = 17) were used for 3D model generation. Photogrammetry was performed using Agisoft Metashape and reference 3D models were generated using a GOM ATOS 80 scanner. Focus stacking was explored as a method of enhancing 3D model detail. Differences between the photogrammetric and reference models were assessed using CloudCompare and the quality of the surface detail was examined quantitatively using Occlusal Fingerprint Analysis.
Photogrammetric model generation was highly replicable and the tooth models produced closely approximated the overall geometry of those derived from the structured light scanner. Dental wear facet area measurements on the photogrammetric models differed significantly, however, from those derived from the structured light scanning reference models.
Photogrammetry can create virtual dental models from which crude quantitative size and shape data can be obtained. Finer scale surface details are not accurately reproduced on SfM models using the methods outlined in the current article due to high levels of surface noise.
最近 3D 模型生成方法的大量涌现,使人们能够开发出新的方法来分析牙齿的形态、功能和磨损。本文评估运动结构(Structure-from-motion,SfM)摄影测量术是否能够生成牙齿的虚拟 3D 模型,这些模型的质量是否足以评估细微的表面细节,如牙齿的宏观磨损模式。参考模型是使用高分辨率结构光扫描仪生成的,以评估生成的摄影测量模型的准确性。
使用人类个体磨牙的石膏模型,来自切斯特的圣迈克尔利滕(St. Michael's Litten),后中世纪组合(n = 17),用于 3D 模型生成。摄影测量是使用 Agisoft Metashape 进行的,参考 3D 模型是使用 GOM ATOS 80 扫描仪生成的。探索了聚焦堆叠作为增强 3D 模型细节的方法。使用 CloudCompare 评估摄影测量模型和参考模型之间的差异,并使用咬合指纹分析(Occlusal Fingerprint Analysis)定量检查表面细节的质量。
摄影测量模型生成具有高度可重复性,生成的牙齿模型非常接近结构光扫描仪获得的整体几何形状。然而,摄影测量模型上的牙齿磨损面区域测量值与结构光扫描参考模型得出的值有显著差异。
摄影测量术可以从牙齿中创建虚拟模型,从中可以获得粗略的定量尺寸和形状数据。在本文所述的方法中,由于表面噪声水平较高,SfM 模型无法准确再现更细微的表面细节。