Johannessen Lene N, Grimstad Hans Jørgen, Skjetne Jens Emil, Myklebust Ida Nord, Svendsen Kristin V Hirsch
Department of Industrial Economics and Technology Management, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), Trondheim, Norway.
Department of Occupational Hygiene, Thelma Indoor Air & Working Environment AS, Trondheim, Norway.
J Occup Environ Hyg. 2020 Oct;17(10):495-503. doi: 10.1080/15459624.2020.1798453. Epub 2020 Aug 10.
The Internet of Things (IoT) explores new perspectives and possible improvements in risk assessment practices and shows potential to measure long-term and real-time occupational exposure. This may be of value when monitoring gases with short-term maximum levels and for time-weighted average (TWA) concentrations used in standard measuring practices. A functional embedded system was designed using low-cost carbon monoxide (CO) electrochemical sensors and long-range-wide-area-network radio communication technology (LoRaWAN) was used to enable internet connectivity. This system was utilized to monitor gas levels continuously in the working atmosphere of an incineration plant over a 2-month period. The results show that stable and long-term continuous data transfer was enabled by LoRaWAN, which proved useful for detecting rapid changes in gas levels. However, it was observed that raw data from the low-cost sensors did not meet the NIOSH accuracy criteria of 25% of the estimated true concentration based on field data from a co-located gas detector that met the NIOSH accuracy criteria. The new IoT technologies and CO sensor networks shows potential for remote monitoring of exposure in order to: (1) detect rapid changes in CO and other possible hazardous airborne gases; and (2) show the dynamic range of real-time data that may be hazardous for workers in the sampled areas. While the IoT low-cost sensors appear to be useful as a sentinel for monitoring hazardous atmospheres containing CO, the more useful finding may be showing real-time changes and the dynamic range of exposures, thus shedding light on the transient and toxic nature of airborne hazards. More importantly, the low-cost CO sensors are not a clear substitute for the more costly real-time gas detectors that perform within the NIOSH accuracy criteria.
物联网(IoT)探索了风险评估实践中的新视角和可能的改进,并显示出测量长期和实时职业暴露的潜力。这在监测具有短期最高水平的气体以及标准测量实践中使用的时间加权平均(TWA)浓度时可能具有价值。使用低成本的一氧化碳(CO)电化学传感器设计了一个功能嵌入式系统,并使用长距离广域网无线通信技术(LoRaWAN)实现互联网连接。该系统用于在两个月的时间内连续监测焚烧厂工作环境中的气体水平。结果表明,LoRaWAN实现了稳定且长期的连续数据传输,这被证明对检测气体水平的快速变化很有用。然而,观察到低成本传感器的原始数据不符合美国国家职业安全与健康研究所(NIOSH)的准确性标准,即基于来自符合NIOSH准确性标准的同地气体探测器的现场数据,估计真实浓度的25%。新的物联网技术和CO传感器网络显示出远程监测暴露的潜力,以便:(1)检测CO和其他可能有害的空气传播气体的快速变化;(2)显示可能对采样区域的工人有害的实时数据的动态范围。虽然物联网低成本传感器似乎可用作监测含CO危险环境的哨兵,但更有用的数据可能是显示实时变化和暴露的动态范围,从而揭示空气传播危害的瞬态和毒性本质。更重要的是,低成本的CO传感器并不能明确替代在NIOSH准确性标准范围内运行的更昂贵的实时气体探测器。