Universidad Politécnica de Madrid.
University of Zaragoza.
Res Q Exerc Sport. 2022 Mar;93(1):16-25. doi: 10.1080/02701367.2020.1788699. Epub 2020 Sep 9.
Physical activity on prescription (PAP) is being introduced in healthcare systems around the world. To apply a successful treatment is as important as to know if the patient is able to follow-up. In order to contribute to the development of effective PAP strategies, we have analyzed PAP-related adherence factors with a multi-dimensional approach. PAP adherence factors in studies published in the WoS, Pubmed, and PsycInfo were reviewed, according to the WHO five dimensions adherence model. In a setting of prediction or adherence analysis of adults with high-risk factors or chronic diseases, the methods used to measure physical activity (PA), PAP treatments, PAP adherence, and mentioned theories related to human behavior change were analyzed. A total of 32 studies fulfilled our inclusion criteria. According to the WHO five dimensions adherence model, these total clustered adherence variables were observed: social/economic (n = 100), healthcare system/healthcare team (n = 18), condition-related (n = 61), therapy-related (n = 20), and patient-related (n = 47). PAP adherence has mainly been measured by adherence to measurement methods and by calculating attended versus total sessions scheduled. PA level was measured mainly by questionnaires and exercise referrals were the most frequent PAP resource in analyzed studies. Transtheoretical model of behavior change was the theory most referenced. A lack of considering health system/healthcare-team factors and therapy-related factors has been identified, as most studies only analyze social/economic factors in non-pharmacological PAP adherence studies in healthcare settings. A multidimensional approach should be adopted to analyze PAP adherence in healthcare settings.
运动处方(PAP)正在全球医疗系统中推广。应用成功的治疗方法与了解患者是否能够跟进同样重要。为了为有效的 PAP 策略的发展做出贡献,我们采用多维方法分析了与 PAP 相关的依从性因素。根据世界卫生组织(WHO)的五个维度依从性模型,对在 WoS、Pubmed 和 PsycInfo 上发表的与 PAP 依从性相关的研究进行了综述。在预测或分析有高风险因素或慢性疾病的成年人的依从性分析中,分析了用于测量身体活动(PA)、PAP 治疗、PAP 依从性的方法以及与人类行为改变相关的理论。共有 32 项研究符合我们的纳入标准。根据世界卫生组织的五个维度依从性模型,观察到这些总聚类的依从性变量:社会/经济(n=100)、医疗体系/医疗团队(n=18)、与病情相关(n=61)、与治疗相关(n=20)和与患者相关(n=47)。PAP 依从性主要通过对测量方法的依从性和计算计划的总治疗次数与实际治疗次数的比例来衡量。PA 水平主要通过问卷进行测量,而在分析研究中,运动推荐是最常见的 PAP 资源。行为变化的跨理论模型是引用最多的理论。研究发现,缺乏对医疗体系/医疗团队因素和治疗相关因素的考虑,因为大多数研究仅分析了医疗环境中非药物 PAP 依从性研究中的社会/经济因素。在医疗环境中分析 PAP 依从性时,应采用多维方法。