Shehata Mohamed Hk, Abouzeid Enjy, Wasfy Nourhan F, Abdelaziz Adel, Wells Ray L, Ahmed Samar A
Department of Family and Community Medicine, Arab Gulf University, Bahrain; Helwan University, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo, Egypt.
Medical Education Department, Faculty of Medicine, Suez Canal University, Egypt.
J Med Educ Curric Dev. 2020 Aug 27;7:2382120520951819. doi: 10.1177/2382120520951819. eCollection 2020 Jan-Dec.
Coronavirus (COVID19) appears to be an inflection point that is forcing a disruption in medical education.
The study aims to explore how medical schools in Egypt responded to COVID-19 pandemic regarding teaching and learning/assessment for undergraduate students.
A mixed method exploratory 2-phase study was conducted. Data was collected through a questionnaire and focus groups.
The responses of the participants were categorized according to main themes; University preparedness, Role of faculty in the transition, Role of ME units/Departments/National/Regional bodies in the transition, Role of Egyptian Knowledge Bank, New teaching methods/strategies, New assessment methods/strategies and Projection into the future. The staff level of preparedness for that unexpected shift was evaluated as optimum to high and a good leadership support was reported by 70% of them. They reported conflicting views about the proper role of medical education units but reinforced the idea of Egyptian Knowledge Bank's crucial role in this transition. Additionally, 64.1% of the participants identified a clinical skills teaching challenge and 76.3% of them reported absence of alternative methods for summative assessment. Finally, there is a communication problem with the students that leads to their detachment.
Individuals moved faster than bodies and relied on support existing outside the universities when catastrophe happened. Many recommendations emerged including the need to integrate online learning into the curriculum at favorable percentages.
冠状病毒(COVID-19)似乎是一个转折点,正在迫使医学教育发生变革。
本研究旨在探讨埃及的医学院校在本科教学和学习/评估方面如何应对COVID-19大流行。
进行了一项混合方法探索性两阶段研究。通过问卷调查和焦点小组收集数据。
参与者的回答根据主要主题进行分类;大学准备情况、教师在转型中的作用、医学教育单位/部门/国家/地区机构在转型中的作用、埃及知识库的作用、新的教学方法/策略、新的评估方法/策略以及对未来的预测。对工作人员应对这一意外转变的准备水平评估为最佳至高,70%的人报告有良好的领导支持。他们对医学教育单位的适当作用存在不同看法,但强化了埃及知识库在这一转型中关键作用的观点。此外,64.1%的参与者指出临床技能教学存在挑战,76.3%的人报告缺乏总结性评估的替代方法。最后,与学生存在沟通问题,导致他们产生疏离感。
当灾难发生时,个人的行动比机构更快,并且依赖大学外部现有的支持。提出了许多建议,包括需要以适当比例将在线学习纳入课程。