Department of Microbiology, Immunology, and Infectious Diseases, College of Medicine and Medical Sciences, Arabian Gulf University, Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain.
Medical Education Unit, College of Medicine and Medical Sciences, Arabian Gulf University, Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain.
BMC Med Educ. 2022 May 30;22(1):411. doi: 10.1186/s12909-022-03346-2.
The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted all spheres of society including medical education and healthcare systems. In response to the pandemic, there has been a transition in medical education practice from traditional forms of teaching to online instruction delivery and virtual learning. Effective clinical microbiology education involves a combination of 'hands-on' practical learning and instructional delivery of scientific knowledge. Microbiology practical laboratories are critical learning environments offering 'hands-on' learning experiences that cannot be replicated through online learning. We conducted a mixed-methods study to understand the perception of online and face-to-face microbiology laboratory sessions among the medical students and microbiology faculty at Arabian Gulf University (AGU).
The study participants were third and fourth-year undergraduate medical students and faculty involved in delivering microbiology labs at AGU. The questionnaire consisted of questions ranging from perceived learning style to attitude towards online delivery of microbiology curriculum. After the questionnaire administration (google form), focus group discussion (FGD) was conducted for students and microbiology faculty separately.
Among 168 students, 50.6% preferred face-to-face lab sessions as compared to 30.4% who preferred online labs, and 51.8% considered online labs to be an essential addition to face-to-face labs. Among the faculty, 85.7% preferred the face-to-face mode of teaching. All the faculty (100%) disagreed that all the microbiology labs teaching should be online. 57.2% considered online labs to be an essential addition to traditional face-to-face labs. Both faculty and students hold that a blended mode of instructional delivery is vital and indispensable for the transfer of skills and knowledge for microbiology students.
The blended mode of delivering microbiology laboratory sessions in medical school is successful and well-received by both students and faculty. Students take the responsibility for furthering their own learning and understanding of concepts. Instructors have also noticed that blending learning strategies also successfully enhances the development of cognitive skills and problem-solving abilities in students. A review of the microbiology lab curriculum is necessary to identify content areas that can be delivered effectively through online, face-to-face lab sessions, or both, supported with appropriate tools and infrastructure.
COVID-19 大流行影响了社会的各个领域,包括医学教育和医疗保健系统。为应对大流行,医学教育实践已从传统教学形式转变为在线教学和虚拟学习。有效的临床微生物学教育需要将“实践”和科学知识的传授相结合。微生物学实践实验室是重要的学习环境,提供“实践”学习经验,这些经验无法通过在线学习来复制。我们进行了一项混合方法研究,以了解阿拉伯海湾大学(AGU)的医学生和微生物学教师对在线和面对面微生物学实验室课程的看法。
研究参与者包括第三年和第四年的医学生以及在 AGU 教授微生物学实验室的教师。问卷包括从感知学习方式到对微生物学课程在线教学的态度等问题。在问卷调查(谷歌表单)之后,对学生和微生物学教师分别进行了焦点小组讨论(FGD)。
在 168 名学生中,50.6%的人更喜欢面对面的实验室课程,而 30.4%的人更喜欢在线实验室课程,51.8%的人认为在线实验室课程是面对面实验室课程的重要补充。在教师中,85.7%的人更喜欢面对面的教学模式。所有教师(100%)都不同意所有的微生物学实验室教学都应该在线进行。57.2%的人认为在线实验室课程是传统面对面实验室课程的重要补充。教师和学生都认为混合式教学对于向微生物学学生传授技能和知识是至关重要和不可或缺的。
在医学院中,混合式微生物学实验室课程的教学是成功的,受到学生和教师的欢迎。学生承担着进一步学习和理解概念的责任。教师也注意到,混合学习策略还成功地提高了学生的认知技能和解决问题的能力。有必要对微生物学实验室课程进行审查,以确定可以通过在线、面对面实验室课程或两者结合的方式有效教授的内容领域,并提供适当的工具和基础设施。