Moss Cami, Kuche Desalegn, Bekele Tesfaye Hailu, Salasibew Mihretab, Ayana Girmay, Abera Andinet, Eshetu Solomon, Dangour Alan D, Allen Elizabeth
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom.
Ethiopian Public Health Institute, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Curr Dev Nutr. 2020 Aug 21;4(9):nzaa139. doi: 10.1093/cdn/nzaa139. eCollection 2020 Sep.
Well-trained anthropometrists are essential for the delivery of high-quality anthropometric data used to evaluate public health nutrition interventions. Scant data are currently available on the precision of data collected by large teams of anthropometrists employed for nutrition surveys in low-income country settings.
The purpose of this study was to assess the precision of child midupper arm circumference (MUAC) and length/height measurements taken by fieldworkers training for nutrition survey deployment.
Following 3 d of training, an anthropometry standardization exercise was conducted in small teams of trainees at 7 sites in the Amhara region of Ethiopia. In groups of 2-4, trainee anthropometrists ( = 79) each measured 16 children aged 6-47 mo ( = 336) twice for MUAC and length/height. Both intraobserver and interobserver precision were analyzed using technical error of measurement (TEM), relative TEM, coefficient of reliability (), and repeatability metrics. Bland-Altman limits of agreement were calculated for intraobserver measurements.
Intraobserver TEM was between 0.00 and 0.57 cm for MUAC (Bland-Altman 95% limits of agreement: -0.50 to 0.54 cm) and between 0.04 and 2.58 cm for length/height measurements (Bland-Altman 95% limits of agreement: -1.43 to 1.41 cm). Interobserver TEM was between 0.09 and 0.43 cm for MUAC and between 0.06 and 2.98 cm for length/height measurements. A high proportion of trainees achieved intraobserver >0.95 (MUAC: 95%; length/height: 97%). Most teams also achieved interobserver >0.95 (MUAC: 90%; length/height: 95%).
Large numbers of anthropometrists (>75) in low-income settings can attain satisfactory precision in anthropometry following training and standardization. These protocols permit researchers to assess trainees, identify individuals who have not achieved the desired level of precision, and retrain or adjust roles prior to survey deployment.
训练有素的人体测量师对于提供用于评估公共卫生营养干预措施的高质量人体测量数据至关重要。目前,关于低收入国家环境中受雇进行营养调查的大批人体测量师所收集数据的精度,可获得的数据很少。
本研究的目的是评估接受营养调查部署培训的现场工作人员所测量的儿童上臂中部周长(MUAC)和身长/身高的精度。
经过3天的培训后,在埃塞俄比亚阿姆哈拉地区的7个地点对实习人员小组进行了人体测量标准化练习。实习人体测量师(n = 79)以2 - 4人一组,每人对16名6 - 47个月大的儿童(n = 336)进行两次MUAC和身长/身高测量。使用测量技术误差(TEM)、相对TEM、可靠性系数()和重复性指标分析了观察者内和观察者间的精度。计算了观察者内测量的Bland - Altman一致性界限。
MUAC的观察者内TEM在0.00至0.57厘米之间(Bland - Altman 95%一致性界限:-0.50至0.54厘米),身长/身高测量的观察者内TEM在0.04至2.58厘米之间(Bland - Altman 95%一致性界限:-1.43至1.41厘米)。MUAC的观察者间TEM在0.09至0.43厘米之间,身长/身高测量的观察者间TEM在0.06至2.98厘米之间。高比例的实习人员实现了观察者内>0.95(MUAC:95%;身长/身高:97%)。大多数小组也实现了观察者间>0.95(MUAC:90%;身长/身高:95%)。
低收入环境中的大量人体测量师(>75名)在经过培训和标准化后,可在人体测量中获得令人满意的精度。这些方案使研究人员能够评估实习人员,识别未达到所需精度水平的个体,并在调查部署前进行再培训或调整角色。