Department of Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Department of Project Leadership, IQVIA, Seoul, Korea.
J Korean Med Sci. 2020 Sep 14;35(36):e329. doi: 10.3346/jkms.2020.35.e329.
The number of clinical trials conducted in Korea continues to increase and an increasing proportion focus on severe and rare incurable diseases. After the start of the severe acute respiratory syndrome, coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (KCDC) developed guidelines to prevent the spread of infection. This study evaluated the impact of COVID-19 and the KCDC guideline on the conduct of clinical research in Korea. The purpose was to develop recommendations on how to minimize the risk of infection while enabling subjects to take part in the trials if no better alternative treatment options were available.
The impact on subject's scheduled visits and major milestones of clinical trials in Korea were measured by conducting a survey among clinical project manager (CPMs) working at global clinical research organization. The policy on monitor's access to hospital and site initiation meetings was investigated through correspondence with clinical trial center of 39 hospitals. The Top 25 pharmaceutical companies' official press and public clinical trial registry database were used to analyze companies' trial strategy during the pandemic and COVID-19 clinical research status, respectively.
Of 85 CPMs, 12% reported that trial subjects' scheduled visits had been affected in their project. Monitors' access to hospital for source data verification was restricted at all sites in February 2020. Accordingly, 43% of 105 CPMs reported that the COVID-19 epidemic had an effect on study major milestones and data cleaning and database lock accounted for > 60% of milestones affected. In addition, 87% sites advised not to have site initiation meetings and 52% pharmaceutical companies suspended recruitment or new study start-up due to the pandemic. On the other hands, the number of COVID-19 related clinical trials increased rapidly in Korea and worldwide, with investigator-initiated trials accounting for 47% and 63% of all trials locally and globally, respectively. Most trials were phase 2 and were in the recruitment stage.
The COVID-19 and the KCDC guideline influenced all parties involved in clinical trials in Korea. In order to ensure the safety and well-being of trial subjects during the pandemic, new approaches are required for clinical trials to respond to the impact actively. Method of non-contact is developed to replace and supplement the face-to-face contact and alternatives to reduce the travel is introduced to decrease the risk of infection for all trial participants in whole trial process. The relevant regulations should be developed and the guidelines for foreign countries need to be adopted in accordance with the situation in Korea. COVID-19 trial is rapidly increasing worldwide and continuous support of health authorities, regulation, and facilities is required for developing the treatments with protecting all trial participants.
在韩国进行的临床试验数量持续增加,越来越多的临床试验针对严重和罕见的不治之症。在严重急性呼吸系统综合症,即 2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)爆发后,韩国疾病控制与预防中心(KCDC)制定了预防感染传播的指南。本研究评估了 COVID-19 和 KCDC 指南对韩国临床研究开展的影响。目的是在没有更好的替代治疗方案的情况下,制定如何在最小化感染风险的同时使受试者能够参与试验的建议。
通过对在全球临床研究组织工作的临床项目经理(CPM)进行调查,衡量 COVID-19 对韩国临床试验中受试者预定访视和主要里程碑的影响。通过与 39 家医院的临床试验中心通信,调查了监察员进入医院和启动会议的政策。使用前 25 家制药公司的官方新闻稿和公共临床试验注册数据库,分别分析公司在大流行期间的试验策略和 COVID-19 临床研究状况。
在 85 名 CPM 中,有 12%的人报告说他们项目中的试验受试者的预定访视受到了影响。2020 年 2 月,所有地点的监察员都被限制进入医院进行原始数据验证。因此,43%的 105 名 CPM 报告说,COVID-19 疫情对研究主要里程碑和数据清理产生了影响,数据库锁定占受影响里程碑的 60%以上。此外,87%的地点建议不要举行启动会议,由于疫情,52%的制药公司暂停了招募或新的研究启动。另一方面,COVID-19 相关临床试验在韩国和全球范围内迅速增加,在当地和全球范围内,分别由研究者发起的试验占所有试验的 47%和 63%。大多数试验为 2 期,处于招募阶段。
COVID-19 和 KCDC 指南影响了韩国所有参与临床试验的各方。为了确保大流行期间试验受试者的安全和福祉,需要为临床试验制定新的方法以积极应对影响。正在开发非接触方法来替代和补充面对面接触,并引入减少旅行的替代方法,以降低整个试验过程中所有试验参与者的感染风险。应制定相关规定,并根据韩国的情况采用针对外国的指南。COVID-19 试验在全球范围内迅速增加,需要卫生当局、监管机构和设施的持续支持,以开发保护所有试验参与者的治疗方法。