Sasangohar Farzan, Bradshaw Major R, Carlson Marianne Millen, Flack James N, Fowler James C, Freeland Diana, Head John, Marder Kate, Orme William, Weinstein Benjamin, Kolman Jacob M, Kash Bita, Madan Alok
Center for Outcomes Research, Houston Methodist Hospital, Houston, TX, United States.
Behavioral Health Clinic, Houston Methodist Hospital, Houston, TX, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2020 Oct 1;22(10):e22523. doi: 10.2196/22523.
As the demand for telepsychiatry increases during the COVID-19 pandemic, the strengths and challenges of telepsychiatry implementation must be articulated to improve clinical practices in the long term. Currently, observations within US contexts are lacking; therefore, we report on the rapid implementation of telepsychiatry and workflow experiences in a psychiatric practice based within a large health care system in southeast Texas with a national catchment area. We discuss the logistics of the implementation, including modes of communication, scheduling, coordination, and capacity; the psychological effects of web-based services, including both the loss of the physical therapeutic environment and the unique interpersonal dynamics experienced in the virtual environment; and postadoption patterns of engagement with our services and with other clinical functions affected by the rapid adaptation to telemedicine. Our art therapy group programming serves as an applied case study, demonstrating the value of a well-managed web-based program (eg, patients were receptive and well-engaged, and they appreciated the continuity of accessible service) as well as the challenges (eg, the need for backup plans and technological fallbacks, managing interruptions and telecommunication learning curves, and working around the difference in resources for art and music therapy between a well-stocked clinical setting versus clients' home spaces). We conclude from our experience that the overall strengths of telepsychiatry include receptive and well-engaged responses from patients as well as the expansion of boundaries, which provides a directly contextualized view into patients' home lives. Challenges and corresponding recommendations include the need for more careful safety planning for high-risk patients; maintaining professional boundaries in the newly informal virtual setting; designing the physical space to both frame the patient encounter and maintain work-life balance for the therapist; allowing for delays and interruptions (including an initial acclimation session); and preserving interprofessional care team collaboration when the physical locations that normally facilitate such encounters are not accessible. We believe that careful observations of the strengths and challenges of telepsychiatry during this pandemic will better inform practices that are considering telepsychiatry adoption both within pandemic contexts and more broadly thereafter.
在新冠疫情期间,随着远程精神病学需求的增加,必须阐明实施远程精神病学的优势和挑战,以便从长远角度改善临床实践。目前,美国国内缺乏相关观察;因此,我们报告了在德克萨斯州东南部一个拥有全国服务范围的大型医疗系统内的一家精神病学诊所中,远程精神病学的快速实施情况及工作流程体验。我们讨论了实施的后勤保障,包括沟通方式、排班、协调和能力;基于网络服务的心理影响,包括实体治疗环境的缺失以及在虚拟环境中体验到的独特人际动态;以及采用我们的服务后与其他受远程医疗快速适应影响的临床功能的参与模式。我们的艺术治疗小组项目作为一个应用案例研究,展示了一个管理良好的基于网络的项目的价值(例如,患者接受度高且参与度良好,他们赞赏可及服务的连续性)以及挑战(例如,需要备用计划和技术支持,管理中断和电信学习曲线,以及应对设备齐全的临床环境与客户家庭空间之间艺术和音乐治疗资源差异的问题)。我们从经验中得出结论,远程精神病学的总体优势包括患者接受度高且参与度良好,以及边界的扩展,这能直接了解患者的家庭生活情况。挑战及相应建议包括需要为高危患者进行更谨慎的安全规划;在新的非正式虚拟环境中保持专业界限;设计物理空间以构建患者诊疗过程并为治疗师维持工作与生活的平衡;允许出现延迟和中断(包括初始适应期);以及当通常促进此类诊疗的实体场所无法使用时,保持跨专业护理团队协作。我们相信,在此次疫情期间对远程精神病学的优势和挑战进行仔细观察,将为在疫情期间及之后更广泛范围内考虑采用远程精神病学的实践提供更好的参考。